u/default3100

I have a Subaru Outback 2015 that I'm planning to trade in. I dropped a box in my garage on the car about a year ago which resulted in a pretty large dent on the fender. When the dent happened a paint chip about 2 inches long came off as well (this spot has since rusted).

Everything else on the car is just normal wear and tear.

I currently have a Carvana appraisal for 8k with damage noted. And a few sight unseen initial dealer appraisals for 7k. However, I have the ability to order the panel and replace it myself for about $250.

Just trying to see if that's worth the time / effort or if I just trade it as is?