u/hello-mottto

SEBI dropped a proposal that would allow companies to pay part of your salary directly into mutual fund units
▲ 439 r/MutualfundsIndia+1 crossposts

SEBI dropped a proposal that would allow companies to pay part of your salary directly into mutual fund units

The industry is already touting this as convenient, seamless, and disciplined, but it's none of those things.

It will turn your monthly hard-earned cash into a permanent, automated subscription service for the mutual fund industry.

India’s retail participation in equity is massive, but it’s still volatile. So, by creating a system where payroll-linked deductions become the norm, the industry is securing a guaranteed, non-stop flow of retail capital.

It turns the workforce into a perpetual cash-cow for fund houses, regardless of whether the market environment is favorable for the average employee.

The regulator has decided that the average Indian is too unreliable to handle their own money, so they’re building a pipe that sucks it directly out of your paycheck and into the stock market.

Change my mind.

u/Broad-Research5220 — 1 day ago

Going by the logic of Modiji to not to buy gold, but is it okay to substitute gold investment with silver? What would be your suggestion, keeping in mind what works the best for our economy and personal portfolio

was thinking about Modi ji’s repeated point that Indians should reduce obsession with buying gold because massive gold imports hurt our economy and weaken the rupee. It made me wonder: is silver a better alternative?

From what I understand, gold is mostly a store of value, while silver also has major industrial uses — solar panels, EVs, electronics, medical equipment, etc. So silver feels slightly more “productive” economically compared to pure gold hoarding.

But from a personal finance perspective, I realized silver and gold play different roles.

Gold is more of a stability asset:

  • inflation hedge
  • crisis protection
  • portfolio diversifier

Silver is much more volatile because it behaves partly like an industrial commodity. It can outperform gold during commodity booms, but it can also crash harder during slowdowns.

reddit.com
u/hello-mottto — 8 days ago