How important is style match for copy editing?

I’m part way through incorporating the notes from my developmental editor, and then I’ll be doing a round of copy edits before publishing.

I’ve heard a lot about the importance of finding someone who connects with and enjoys the voice/ style of the novel. But, how important is that really? Can’t I incorporate my own solutions to the structure/ word choice problems identified, making a match sort of redundant and idealistic? Or is that just making more work for myself?

Partially asking because I’m not my dev editors favourite style to work with, but they’re happy to do the job and we’re on the same continent (an underrated metric). I enjoyed working with them too.

I’m new to the process so any insight on what could go wrong and why would be greatly appreciated!

reddit.com
u/hk_arnold — 7 days ago

It all started when I picked up a new book to read and one of the pages came unglued from the spine. It reminded me how much I miss books with stitches in the pages. A simple joy from a simple time.

A supermassive rabbit hole later, the hours of which I did not (would rather not) track, I’d consumed half of DAS’s bookbinding videos (twice), some of Nik’s - a small side tangent into stitched endbands, a brief glance in fanbinding’s direction - and a whole heap of tips and inspo from this sub. I got to figuring out typesetting and imposition.

And then the real fun began.

Paper grain: I went to all the trouble of printing quattro on A3 to get short grain A4. Silly me, the A3 was short grain and I got long grain A4 anyway. The whole process of formatting, printing and collating was relaxing though. Punching holes and sewing went without a hitch (thank you DAS).

Trimming: I tried three different hand trimming methods. All failed miserably (how does anyone do that without their hands dropping off?? Or is it me? Am I just crazy for trying to hand trim an almost 400 page text block???). To be fair, the chisel method worked great for the first hour - that’s about when I realised I was only through 1/8th. I found a half price guillotine, and took way too much off the fore edge. There’s forever a weird little wave in the head too.

Rounding and backing: Trying to make a shoulder in my hand made press was… fun, but at least my glancing hammering skills are a benefit to backing (now, when I bend nails, it’s in tribute to my emerging bookbinding skills and not just a frustrating mess of random holes and wasted nails). One section wouldn’t roll over. I’m still not sure why.

Edges: my fingernails were too long to be let near smooth edges (the nail marks are a personal touch). The edge painting went pretty good - thanks to an old thread on this sub and the fanbinding community on YT. It is a little patchy and did leak slightly on the first try - but no stuck pages or flaking.

Endbands: I tried a four step pattern with three threads. Silly me. I realised half way and did it right on the second endband. I used macrame thread as a core and contested with an unravelling thread as I sewed. Plus, macrame thread is twisty and too soft, so it pinched and rolled over in spots. I think the thread I used was too thin too. The bead is not as noticeable as I wanted. Some of the anchor points are noticeable (distractingly) inside the book, as well as the tassel (I started at the front of the book for some reason). It’s a fun quirk. Like the close cut margins and slightly patchy edges and crescent shaped notches.

Overall: the book is sturdy (I could club someone with it and it’d come out undented). I love the smell of cloves, lowkey (thank you homemade paste). And it’s just so nice to handle. I may never buy another factory produced book again! (let me dream.)

Help: I’m about to start another project. I’ve found some better thread for endbands (I hope), but I’d love any tips for some of the issues I’ve run into or visible mistakes I might’ve missed? The next book I’m tackling is way shorter (almost half the size), and I’m drawing up a stencil to paint on the cover (nervous it’ll be thick, flaky and lose the fabric texture). I’m doing it as a surprise gift for the author (my brother) and I want to nail it.

u/hk_arnold — 2 months ago