u/lolminna

▲ 21 r/unis

Should Hyeonju, Nana, Yoona, and Seowon not be considered 5th gen idols, just idols in a 5th gen group?

Question in the title.

I came across this thread that pretty much implied that idols who redebuted shouldn't be considered of that gen. Lee Hyori is considered a 1st gen idol despite becoming a soloist later, and Shinee Taemin will always be known as a 2nd gen idol despite redebuting multiple times.

Hyeonju debuted in 2017 which would make her a 3rd gen idol, Yoona debuted in 2021, same with Seowon but as a soloist, and Nana debuted a year later in Japan which would make them 4th gen idols.

I'm also not certain if Elisia's early career as an actress should be counted as a debut.

reddit.com
u/lolminna — 5 days ago
▲ 54 r/unis

No video. They performed SWICY again.

I am happy that they're OT8 again, and that Yoona has bangs now.

But idk, do Korean award shows hate Japanese songs? Does FnF have a contract that states you can only do Japanese songs in Japan or in Japanese related events?

What is it, FnF? I just watched the girls go thru the motions again instead of, y'know, promoting their latest song.

reddit.com
u/lolminna — 26 days ago