u/majomista

Enharmonic accuracy or ... ?

I'm writing a quartet for classical guitar in C#m containing arpeggiations of these held chords: C#m, E/B, G#m/B, D#/A#.

The final chord currently contains Fx. This makes harmonic sense as it keeps the intervals correct, and therefore identifies the chord correctly, but I feel like I'm being fussy writing the arpeggio as A# Fx D# A# rather than A# G D# A#.

This is especially because I don't need to distinguish between different types of F or G in the chord (ie the music is firmly diatonic so I'm not using the double sharp to limit unnecessary accidentals) and so having the double sharp in there feels like I'm being technically correct but a bit fastidious.

What should I do?

Do I stick with harmonic accuracy or give the musician the more familiar spelling even though that obscures the harmonic intention (and makes me look harmonically illiterate!)?

I would never write a D major chord as D Gb A so why am I getting worked up about D# major as D# Fx A#?

Any advice greatly received!

reddit.com
u/majomista — 18 hours ago
▲ 2 r/classicalguitar+1 crossposts

I want to make a saddle from a blank for my classical guitar.

Can I get some advice on typical materials and equipment I’m going to need to do this well?

I’m not set yet on making it from bone or Tusq.

My current saddle didn’t have extra compensation on any one string (just the regular incline) and the guitar had good intonation across prior to the saddle breaking.

Any advice or pointers would be greatly appreciated. Thanks in advance.

reddit.com
u/majomista — 23 days ago