What's the big deal over woodwinds as solo instruments?
i've only been in this activity for 4 years so take this with a grain of salt, and i also want to clarify that i don't think woodwinds should ever go beyond being solo instruments
i see a lot of people pretty mad about this and just wanted to know why, as they're not at all in the main instrumentation and designed to be used sparingly, and we've had other solo instruments be legal for quite some time (guitar, sitar, keytar, harmonica, cello, violin, etc) too.
the main instrumentation is still percussion and three valved, bell front horns. brass instruments that don't fall into that category are used for 1-2 movements at most. so... what's the big deal? did it really change much to legalize these as solo instruments? i understand criticism if the usage doesn't scream "this NEEDED to be a woodwind solo" because that's perfectly valid, but i don't really get being mad for the sake of being mad here