Ranking #1 on Google doesn't mean ChatGPT will recommend you.
TL;DR: SEO is still important, but a big myth right now is that good Google rankings = good AI visibility. From my experience that is not true.
I've been building startups for years and until recently, I assumed if you ranked well on Google, the top LLMs would naturally pick you up too.
By now, it's fairly well known that AI pulls from way more than just search rankings. E.g. Reddit, review sites, docs, GitHub, comparison pages etc.
When building my latest tool I realised this is actually hilariously prevalent. ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini and co all pull from sometimes the most random locations. I am collating a comprehensive list of places, registries and domains which are commonly cited, but it really is surprising how little Google ranking seems to correlate with AI visibility. I say "seems" deliberately there as there is still decent correlation, just much weaker than you would expect. Now AI visibility optimisation is more important than ever
The future is no longer just SEO, but SEO + AI visibility
Thoughts?