41 Theatres = Complete!
103 productions, 121 performances, 30 years. From my first Broadway show at age 11 (Les Miserables) to yesterday at the matinee for The Balusters, I have completed the set. I went on a ton of bus trips during my teenage years, so there are a lot from the 1998-2002 era, and I had about a 5-6 year break when I was living in Boston. I didn't realize this was a goal for myself until earlier this year - and I can say the only one I visited just for completion was Stephen Sondheim since I had never really been interested in & Juliet.
Top 3 Most Visited Theatres: Longacre (9), Nederlander (8), Shubert (6)
-----
Al Hirschfeld: Sweet Charity, How to Succeed in Business, Moulin Rouge (2x), A Tale of Two Cities
Ambassador: Bring in da Noise Bring in da Funk (2x)
August Wilson: Funny Girl, Jersey Boys, Cabaret, Little Women
Belasco: Ain't No Mo, Girl From the North Country
Bernard B. Jacobs: Company (2x)
Booth: Kimberly Akimbo
Broadhurst: Cats The Jellicle Ball, Fosse, Equus
Broadway: Bombay Dreams, Gatsby
Circle in the Square: Rocky Horror Show, American Buffalo
Ethel Barrymore: The Life, Paradise Square, Othello
Eugene O'Neill: Grease, Spring Awakening
Gerald Schoenfeld: A Chorus Line, Jeykll & Hyde
Gershwin: Showboat, Riverdance
Hayes: Between Riverside and Crazy, Take Me Out, The Kite Runner
Hudson: Every Brilliant Thing
Imperial: Les Miserables, Billy Elliott, Chess
James Earl Jones: The Cripple of Innishman, Fear of 13
John Golden: Topdog/Underdog, Hangmen, Operation Mincemeat
Lena Horne: The Odd Couple, Six
Longacre: Macbeth, Leopoldstadt, Two Strangers Carry a Cake, Dead Outlaw (6x)
Lunt-Fontanne: Sweeney Todd (2x), The Addams Family, Death Becomes Her, Beauty and the Beast
Lyceum: A Strange Loop, Oh Mary
Lyric: Harry Potter and the Cursed Child
Majestic: Phantom of the Opera, Gypsy, Beaches
Marquis: Annie Get Your Gun, The Drowsy Chaperone, Beetlejuice, Once Upon a One More Time
Minskoff: Saturday Night Fever, Fiddler on the Roof
Music Box: Deuce, Giant
Nederlander: Rent (5x but this is a guess... might have been more?), Shucked (2x), Schmigadoon
Neil Simon: The Music Man, Swan Lake
New Amsterdam: The Lion King
Palace: Aida, West Side Story, The Lost Boys
Richard Rogers: Seussical, Footloose, In the Heights, Hamilton, Romeo & Juliet
Samuel J. Friedman: The Balusters
Shubert: Chicago (2x), Spamalot, To Kill a Mockingbird, POTUS, Some Like it Hot
St. James: The Producers, Into the Woods, Sunset Boulevard, Titanique
Stephen Sondheim: & Juliet
Studio 54: Cabaret, Rocky Horror Show (3x so far), Pictures From Home
Todd Haimes: 1776
Vivian Beaumont: Contact, South Pacific, Ragtime
Walter Kerr: Grey Gardens, The Heiress, Hadestown
Wintergarden: Cats, Mamma Mia, The Music Man
And there we have it! There are definitely some long running shows I notably haven't seen yet (Hi, Wicked and Book of Mormon!) Trying to remember what year I saw Beauty and the Beast or Chicago to get the theatres right was a good test for my memory lol.
Of all the theatres, seeing Dead Outlaw so many times made the Longacre feel like home (lol) so if asked, that's probably my favorite, just because it feels comfy to me and I have such fond memories there. I used to hate on the St. James, but sitting in orchestra was a whole different experience. Some of the theatres I haven't been in for a very long time so I can't say I remember the theatre itself very well lol (ex: I remember nothing about the Ambassador except lil tap dancer me being in the front row mesmerized and Savion Glover giving me a broken drumstick off the stage lol)
What's next? Is conquering off-Broadway a thing?
EDIT: OMG I MISSED ONE. Romeo & Juliet at the Richard Rogers. Adding it in.