u/tmarva_

SSD was in SATAFIRM S11 state, firmware repaired, GPT initialized by mistake — chances of data recovery?

Hi everyone,

I'm trying to understand if I still have a chance of recovering data from an SSD after a series of events.

Device:

  • SSD: Gigabyte GP-GSTFS31480GNTD 480GB
  • Controller: Phison PS3111-S11
  • Original issue: drive became stuck in SATAFIRM S11 state and was no longer functioning normally.

What happened:

  1. The SSD failed and started showing as SATAFIRM S11.
  2. I used Phison Flash ID and identified:
    • Controller: PS3111
    • Firmware family: SBFMP1.3
  3. I used an S11 firmware repair/flashing tool and flashed SBFMP1.3_21102020.BIN.
  4. The SSD came back to life and is now detected properly as:
    • Gigabyte GP-GSTFS31480GNTD
    • CrystalDiskInfo shows:
      • Health: 100%
      • 0 host writes
      • 0 hours
      • Firmware: SBFMP1.3
  5. Windows then prompted me to initialize the disk in Disk Management.
  6. I selected GPT initialization (I did NOT create partitions, format, or install anything afterward).
  7. I almost installed Linux to the drive but stopped before any installation happened.

Current situation:

I connected the SSD to another PC and started a DMDE Full Scan:

  • NTFS
  • FAT
  • exFAT
  • ExtFS
  • RAW signatures enabled

No writing has been done after GPT initialization.

Questions:

  • Did GPT initialization likely overwrite only the partition structures or could it have caused more damage?
  • Is there a possibility TRIM already wiped data?
  • Since the drive had previously been stuck in SATAFIRM S11 state, could firmware failure have prevented TRIM from executing normally?
  • Is DMDE the right approach here or should I stop immediately and clone the SSD first?
  • Does reflashing an S11 SSD itself reduce recovery chances?

I understand SSD recovery is much harder than HDD recovery due to FTL/TRIM behavior, but I'm trying to determine whether I still have a realistic chance before doing anything else.

Thanks.

I’m not an expert and I may be misunderstanding parts of what I wrote. I followed guides and advice while trying to save the drive, so please let me know if I’m making wrong assumptions.

EDIT: At the time I flashed it, I believed the SSD itself was the goal. I was trying to get a functional drive again after seeing SATAFIRM S11 and following common repair videos/tutorials. I was told only afterwards that the data on it (old family videos) was actually important.

reddit.com
u/tmarva_ — 4 days ago