
Tank review: A33 Assault Tank “Excelsior”
Excelsior
Notes:
- Release Date: OLD
- Balance history? Eh just the 8.2 global HP changes
- Dispersion:
- Turret: 0.16
- Movement: 0.28
- Weight: 41 tons
- Gun depression:
- Front: 9
- Sides: progressive to 13
- Rear: 4
Overview:
- A Fat cromwell? Here is the A33 heavy tank.
Pros:
- Pref MM
- Tad above average VR
- 2nd fastest heavy
- Fastest turret traverse
- Great hull traverse
- 13 degrees of gun depression!
- Strong front armor
Neutral:
- Average HP
- Average camo
Cons:
- Lower damage
- Lower DPM
- BAD gun handling and accuracy
- Poor standard pen as natural of a pref tank.
- Actually decent premium pen
- Low shell velocity
- Low unhistorical ammo capacity.
- High fire chance
- Front mounted ammo rack
- 2nd lowest economic bonus.
Armor:
- Its not half bad for a tier 5 considering its mobility.
- Turret:
- Front: a simple flat 114mm. It can block some stand ammo at tier 5 but being flat means it cant be angled (don't bother angling the turret).
- Side: a generally flat 92mm. With the turret being a flatter octagon, it has some angle but don't rely on it. It serves its purpose against lower tier tanks and HE.
- Rear: Also a flat 92mm. So about the same as the sides.
- Roof: have to save some weight somewhere, so this is only 25.4mm. Its not that visible so easy enough hide from normal engagements (outside long range durp shots or arty).
- Cupola: its very small and is a angled 92mm meaning they might as well shoot the front of the turret.
- Hull:
- Flat front: a simple flat 114mm. Same comment as the turret front. Blocks standard ammo and some premium ammo from lower tiers.
- Angled front: The upper section is actually pretty decent at 68.9mm at 71 degrees making it a auto bounce and quite strong even if it has a bit less of a angle. Its at least as effective as the flat parts. The lower section is 63.5mm at 63.5 degrees… heh. Anyhow its about 143mm effective, or about 120 against AP
- Sides: mmm a mix bag. The inner section is rather thin at 31.75, but does at least prevent overmatch. This is protected by the 20mm tracks and 25.4 side skirts. So it's a mixed bag as it's good against HE and the rare HEAT round but against normal ammo its generally weak (2x overmatch makes most guns a good deal more effective).
- Rear: quite mixed. We got the flat mid section that's 108 which is quite good. The lower section being a flat 63mm and the upper a simple 44 that while angled at 63 but still vulnerable to most AP ammo. Then we got the lowest section thats 88mm at 53 to block most shots. So yea mixed bag and you might get lucky and block stuff with the 108mm plate.
- Roof + Floor: eh not great but this is only tier 5 and UK is not known for thick roof armor. Anyhow the value is only 19mm which wont block much outside the 57mm guns which are still common enough.
Gameplay:
- With 9 degrees of gun depression it works enough over most hills, but to really use the full 13 you have to pretty much aim directly over the sides. This is a tad awkward but you make due with what you have.
- As for what to do depends on if you are top tier or not as it has enough front armor to bully tier 4 and 5 tanks.
- If you're top tier you can play front line heavy tank, though there is enough tier 5 (not to mention all the TD’s) that have enough pen to go through your armor. At that point your best bet if to try to side scrape.
- Facing tier 6’s (or all tier 5) then your main gun will not be the best. Its pen is usable and you might have to load a decent amount of premium, but the main issue is how inaccurate it is. You shouldn't fire on the move as the dispersion and base accuracy is just too unusable. Anyhow you are best relegated to a support role or tracking or flaking as its mobile enough to able to do that on some maps. It just makes a decent support tank.
- Equipment:
- Vents
- Optics
- Turbo
- Rammer / grousers
Counter Gameplay:
- Your best bet naturally is just to load gold and aim at the hull to also hit the ammo rack. If your premium pen is not enough or your wallet, then flanking is the best choice. Flanking however will be a bit harder due to the generally decent mobility this tank has compared to other heavies. If you do manage to get side shots then its armor is… so so. Best to try to hit the drive wheel to avoid the side skirts.
- The best counter is just to have decent armor as its gun is limited in not just pen but accuracy so even having weak spot is not necessarily an issue.
Cosmetics:
- Mmmm British box design. Ignoring the shape it is pretty detailed enough. Doesn't have any tanker gear, but basic supplies for tank operation.
- I do like the design of the side escape hatches as even the outer side skirts have doors. We don't get that on a lot of the later tank designs so its always nice to remember this period of history.
- Nothing too much else, got the basic details a tank should have. I suppose i could comment on the engine deck being somewhat unique in shape.
- Cosmetics:
- Emblem: one on each mid side of the turret
- Inscription: one on each forward side of the turret. (would prefer to be moved to the side skirts)
- Flag: rear right side.
General Thoughts:
- This is a nice historic tank to have and does fit in with other mid tier UK tanks.
- Mmm this could probably use some help.
- First off would be to fix the couple inaccuracy in the tank.
- One would be the ammo capacity of 64 should be 80 which still be below average, but its something.
- The second would be to have the side armor to the correct values. Compared to the current 31mm, the front half would be 50.8 and the rear 38mm. This combined with the inch thick side skirt would prove quite a bit of protection and would warrant the the iffy gun handling.
- The fender of track cover armor could be added to the model as just 10mm would be quite useful.
- Depending on how effective the above armor buffs would be adjusting the dispersion a bit would certainly help. Id vote for turret as i can always stand still.
- If they really want to feel cheeky they could do the above armor changes and have the pen match the gun found on the TT tanks so instead of 91/144 it be 120/165. With actually good gun handling and terrain resistances could make it a normal tier 5 heavy probably call it A33/2 or use the shortly used “Commodore” destination. The name Excelsior may not have been used at time design? Eh its in the history article link.
- One thing i think should be changed is the economic bonuses of 40 silver and XP. of the tier 5 pref tanks this is the tied 2nd lowest. The average silver is about 49/50 and the XP about 45. So i could see it getting boosted considering its cousin the T14 has 62/45 so at least 45/45 (we dont need it boosted to the rather OP Churchill 3’s 58/78)
Buy?
- At time of review its available in the Masters of Mayhem season pass so good amount of ya already got it.
- So first off its a tier 5 and thus darn cheap. Base value is 1.5k gold which is… yea dirt cheap compared to some of these other premium tanks. Of course still wait for some form of sale via free xp or silver or heck a trade in if you have a tier 6 you don't like.
- It is available in the premium tech tree so you can purchase this tank directly so that's nice.
- So anyhow as for the tank? Its decent enough though by the fact I mentioned several changes it could use, means it certainly could use some help.
- Not to mention the eco bonuses are not great.
External link: