u/zstillunconvinced22

logan is basically a western and i don't think it works any other way imo

they literally show shane in the middle of it and she says the line at the end. no portal, no team, no city blowing up. just a tired old guy, a car and a kid he didn't ask for. would the same ending hit if it was a normal x-men movie or was the western thing the whole point???

reddit.com
u/zstillunconvinced22 — 13 days ago

spotlight won best picture and i think i've never met anyone who rewatched it

not a knock but i think it's one of the best winners of the decade. saw it once in 2016 and i still remember most of it. it's all phones and filing cabinets and people being polite at each other and somehow that's the scary part. does rewatching even matter for best picture or is that the wrong way to judge it????

reddit.com
u/zstillunconvinced22 — 15 days ago
▲ 29 r/FIlm

The "villain was right all along" reading has quietly become the laziest take in film criticism.

It flatters the viewer into feeling they saw past the movie, when usually they just tuned out the third act. Thanos, Killmonger, the Joker, none of these films are hiding a secret endorsement. They built a coherent monster and trusted the audience to hold two things at once: he has a point, and he is still setting the world on fire to make it. "He was right" keeps the flattering half and throws away the harder one. Which film do you think gets flattened by this the most?

reddit.com
u/zstillunconvinced22 — 1 month ago
▲ 554 r/FIlm

the twist where the villain was right the whole time is the only twist that still works on me every single time

not the villain who was secretly good. the villain who was correct, and the movie just didnt want to admit it until the end

killmonger is probably the one that ruined this for me. his whole point about wakanda hoarding everything while people who look like him suffered everywhere else never actually gets argued down, they just win the fight and change the policy after hes already dead

feels like every other twist runs out of juice after the first viewing once you know its coming. this one still hits because it doesnt need surprise to work, it works because youre forced to actually sit with whether he was right

think its the rarest kind of writing tbh, being willing to let the antagonist win the argument even if he loses the movie

whats a villain whose actual point never really got a good counterargument??

u/zstillunconvinced22 — 2 months ago
▲ 1.1k r/FIlm

luis in ant-man might be a better written character than half the leads marvel has put out

hes barely in the movie compared to the actual cast and he still walks away the most memorable thing in it

feels like writers relax the second theyre not writing the lead. hes just allowed to be a specific weird guy instead of carrying a plot

funniest part is nothing about him is even that complicated, hes just fully himself in every scene hes given

whats a side character with barely any screen time that ended up more memorable than the actual lead

u/zstillunconvinced22 — 2 months ago

anthony hopkins in The Father just quietly falls apart and it's the most unsettling thing I've seen an actor do in years

u/zstillunconvinced22 — 2 months ago
▲ 9 r/FIlm

no third act is good enough to make up for an hour of nothing in the middle

used to think a good ending could save a movie. now i think it just makes you forget how bored you were for the middle hour

wolf of wall street does this to me every single time. that third act hits so hard i forget there's like 40 minutes of yelling in a boardroom before it even gets there

not even mad about it honestly, just annoying that it works on me every time

what's one that got away with this on you and you didn't clock it till way later

reddit.com
u/zstillunconvinced22 — 2 months ago