r/HaileyBaldwinSnark

She finally washed her hair! Also her face looks weirdly different

Not even Bella Thorne escaped 💀 it reminds me of how the Kardashians, mainly Kim, get other celebrities objects, idk feels like destiny swapping or stealing energy.

Can we talk about the absolute mental gymnastics happening on TikTok and Reddit lately? I keep seeing these viral edits claiming that Justin was intentionally casting "Hailey doppelgängers" in his old music videos because she was "always his type." It is honestly hilarious, naive, and relies entirely on toxic confirmation bias and rewriting actual history.
Let’s look at the facts these stans are conveniently ignoring:
1. The "Justin picked them himself" quote is heavily twisted
When creators get called out, their immediate defense is: "But Justin said in an interview he picked the girls himself, bye!" Yeah, no. He meant he had the final approval as the main artist. Standard industry practice: the directors and casting agency filters through hundreds of portfolios, narrows it down to a short-list of 3-5 professional models, and Justin points at one. He wasn't sitting in his room in 2012 searching for girls that looked like a teenager he barely knew at the time.
2. The girls literally look nothing like each other (or Hailey)
The TikTok edits lazily throw together clips of entirely different women to fit the narrative. They use Cailin Russo (Confident), Chanel Celaya (As Long As You Love Me), and Rachel Barnes (Boyfriend).
Cailin is a blonde.
Chanel is a dark-haired brunette with soft features.
Rachel is a tan brunette/dirty blonde who was literally married at the time.
The only thing these women have in common is that they are conventionally attractive, skinny models. That’s it. That’s the "type"—the standard 2010s American pop video aesthetic.
3. The absolute erasure of the Selena Gomez era
This is the wildest part. These theories completely erase the reality of 2011–2014. Justin was publicly, intensely, and messily in love with Selena Gomez during this exact era. In fact, Director X (who directed the Boyfriend video in 2012) openly admitted they specifically looked for a girl who gave off Selena’s vibe because Justin wanted to keep his actual girlfriend happy. Back in 2012, the entire fandom was talking about how the models looked like Selena, not Hailey.
4. Blatant chronological failure
In 2011 (the perfume commercial era they love to bring up), Hailey Baldwin was just a random fan-turned-acquaintance he briefly met once or twice through her dad. She wasn't on his radar as a romantic muse. They didn't start closely hanging out or dating until years later.
It honestly feels like modern shippers are desperately trying to overcompensate for the rocky, controversial start of Justin and Hailey's actual marriage. By inventing this romantic myth that Hailey was "always the blueprint," they try to force a soulmate narrative that never existed back then. It's parasocial revisionist history at its finest.
What do you guys think? Why is the fandom so obsessed with rewriting the Jelena era just to make Hailey seem like she was his lifetime muse since day one?

Had to repost because lurkers sneaked in (this time with more pics)

I heard rumors people in Hollywood don’t like her, bet they did it on purpose. I think they changed it later tho. Remember how the magazine editor or guy said she begged for a cover? Even they see how desperate she is and try to expose her.

pupils are PINPOINTS. he knows people will notice them & still posts 3 photos with his (alleged) opioid eyes.

Zendaya is gorgeous and talented, why would she try to look like the most boring influencer of this time? 😂