r/Mt5

Running my own EA for 4 months this are the current results
▲ 1 r/Mt5

Running my own EA for 4 months this are the current results

So I built my own EA for gold and it's been live about 4 months. Figured I'd just dump the actual numbers here instead of another cherry picked screenshot. DD, win rate, the losers, it's all in there. (low balance account)

I know it's still early and a small sample. And gold's been trending hard this year so honestly part of this is probably just the market cooperating, not some genius edge. Fixed SL every trade, no grid, no martingale, one trade at a time.

Making a 5-10% per month on average 86% winrate currently

Here are some screenshots:

https://preview.redd.it/r11pzd92kgbh1.png?width=1693&format=png&auto=webp&s=276c3826e8d493a18924656e4a79d0d094329723

Mostly posting because I'm curious what people would rip apart first.
Thoughts? Would love to hear some "experts" taking a look at it.

https://preview.redd.it/24w2151xjgbh1.png?width=474&format=png&auto=webp&s=4f0d953a1f8bde474adb9c9de6d6293e929c4359

reddit.com
u/Larsbrahh123 — 14 hours ago
▲ 3 r/Mt5

Struggling to optimize my MT5 EA

Hi everyone,
I’m from a medical background and relatively new to algo trading, so I’d really appreciate some guidance from people with more experience in MT5 strategy development and optimization.
I’m currently trying to build an **MT5 Expert Advisor based on an SMC strategy**. I used Claude to help write the initial script, and I’ve been testing it in **MetaTrader 5** using MT5 historical data.
At the moment, I have a working version of the EA with a defined set of strategy parameters, and I’ve already run both **backtesting** and some **forward testing**.

The problem is that the results are not good at all:
**Very high drawdown**
**Low Sharpe ratio**
**Very low profit / weak overall performance**

So I’m trying to understand **how to properly optimize the parameters** and improve the strategy in a structured way rather than just randomly changing inputs.
**What I’m looking for help with:**
**How would you approach optimizing an MT5 EA like this?**
Specifically, how do you decide which parameters to optimize first, and how do you avoid overfitting?
**What metrics should I prioritize during optimization?**
For example, should I focus more on drawdown, Sharpe ratio, profit factor, net profit, recovery factor, etc.?
**How do you structure proper forward testing in MT5?**
I’ve done some testing already, but I’m not sure if I’m doing it correctly. I’d like to understand the best way to split backtest vs forward test periods and validate whether the strategy has any real robustness.
**For an SMC-based EA specifically, what usually matters most?**
For example:
entry confirmation rules
stop-loss / take-profit logic
session filters
risk management
trailing stop / break-even logic
trade frequency filters
**My current workflow**
EA built in **MT5**
Strategy type: **SMC**
Initial code generated with **Claude**, then tested in MetaTrader
Using MT5 historical data for backtesting
Also ran a small amount of forward testing
**My current issue**
I feel stuck because I can generate results, but I don’t yet know how to improve them systematically. I’m especially struggling with:
reducing drawdown
improving Sharpe / consistency
figuring out whether the strategy logic is bad vs the parameters just being poorly tuned
understanding how to do a proper optimization + forward validation cycle
If anyone is experienced with **MT5 optimization, walk-forward testing, or building profitable EAs**, I’d really appreciate your advice.
If it helps, I can also share:
the **strategy parameters**
**backtest results**
**forward test results**
and the **logic of the EA**
Thanks in advance.

u/No_Confection_391 — 1 day ago
▲ 2 r/Mt5

Is MetaTrader 5 (MT5) still the best trading platform for forex and CFDs, or have you found a better alternative?

I've been looking into different trading platforms, and MT5 seems to be one of the most commonly recommended options for forex and CFD trading.

Before I commit to using it full-time, I'd like to hear from people who have real experience with the platform. How does it perform in terms of charting, order execution, indicators and overall reliability?

Do you think MT5 is suitable for both beginners and experienced traders, or would you recommend a different platform? Any honest feedback, tips or comparisons would be greatly appreciated.

reddit.com
u/ibrahim_40 — 3 days ago
▲ 3 r/Mt5

Attempting to make an EA

I am trying to build an EA. It is so far giving good results when the market is trending but failed to create anything when the market is in a range. Anyone who want to work with me on it

u/Automatic_Rice_1260 — 5 days ago
▲ 1 r/Mt5+1 crossposts

How I used Rust, WASM, and WebGPU to build a low-latency trading terminal that runs entirely in the browser

https://i.redd.it/cxjbbleldkah1.gif

Hey everyone,

I wanted to share a project I’ve been building called CoreCandle. Like a lot of you, I was tired of two major friction points in my trading setup:

  1. The clunkiness of running native desktop platforms (especially on non-Windows machines).

  2. The frustrating execution latency caused by cloud webhooks and centralized mid-layers when using web tools.

If you browse these subreddits often, you might remember my previous posts about the legacy Windows desktop version of this platform. While the desktop app worked well, it had two massive bottlenecks: it locked out Mac/Linux users, and managing local multi-account execution without connection lag was a constant headache.

Instead of trying to patch an old architecture, I decided to completely pivot and rewrite the entire system from scratch for the browser. I used Rust, WebAssembly, and WebGPU to see if I could bring raw desktop performance into a standard web tab. CoreCandle is the result of that total overhaul.

solve this, I built a high-performance trading terminal that shifts all the heavy lifting directly to the user's hardware inside the browser.

To

### The Architecture:

* **WebGPU Core:** Renders thousands of data points, complex indicators, and raw order books smoothly at a locked 60+ FPS without choking the DOM or burning up the CPU.

* **WASM Pipeline:** Handles ultra-fast data serialization and client-side processing.

* **Direct Broker Connections:** Instead of routing your trades through a central server mid-layer (which introduces webhook and execution lag), the app establishes direct, secure client-side WebSocket connections straight to your crypto/forex brokers and MT5 endpoints.

### Why this matters for execution:

By keeping the entire pipeline client-side, your private API keys never touch a third-party server, and order execution times drop significantly because you're bypassing the typical "TradingView -> Webhook Server -> Lambda Function -> Broker" latency loop.

I’m currently gathering feedback from active traders, quants, and engineers to see what features or integrations would be most valuable next.

Happy to answer any questions about the WebGPU render loop or the client-side socket implementation!

reddit.com
u/Defiant_Outcome_570 — 5 days ago
▲ 7 r/Mt5+2 crossposts

Automating My TradingView Pine Script Strategy with a Forex Prop Firm

I have developed and backtested a trading strategy in Pine Script on TradingView, and now I want to automate live trading using it. What are the best ways to automate this strategy, and which forex prop firms are most suitable for automated trading ?

Can anyone guide me?

u/National-Cold-2707 — 9 days ago
▲ 1 r/Mt5

[FOR HIRE] MQL5 EA & Indicator Developer | MT4/MT5 | $30–80 fixed

What I build:

- Expert Advisors (any strategy — trend, scalp, grid, prop firm)

- Custom indicators (any logic)

- Pine Script → MQL5 conversion

- EA debugging/modification

- Copy trading systems

Delivery: 1–5 days. Clean commented code. Source included.

Rate: $30–80 fixed depending on complexity.

DM with your requirements.

reddit.com
u/Algo_trader_MQL — 11 days ago
▲ 5 r/Mt5+2 crossposts

MT5 Backtest Analyser

Hey reddit, I'm a senior software developer and since long time ago I felt the process of analysing, sharing MT5 backtests and strategies with other members was always a hassle, screenshots, downloading html reports etc, so I decided to build StrategyLens.

StrategyLens is free, allows you to analyse your strategies and create portfolios in local, everything stays in your computer, no cloud information is sent unless you decide to share the strategy with other people which has a feature to create a link to share, in that case it does upload raw data of the trades only to the cloud) (never the EA input params).

It has been built also to be mobile friendly, and has some features like prop firm deterministic evaluation based on your strategy.

Feel free to check out, can also be installed as a PWA (Progressive Web App) to act like a desktop application or mobile phone app (ios safari - Add to Home)

Just upload a .htm/html/xlsx MT5 Backtest Report to see your strategy analytics in action.

Feedback is also appreciated.

See you at the charts!

strategy-lens.app
u/alexkyse — 13 days ago