r/NYYankees

▲ 420 r/NYYankees

The Steinbrenner's have been terrible owners dating back to 1973, and were only saved by a small group of scouts who drafted the core of the 90s dynasty 36 years ago.

Between 1978-1996 the Yankees went 17 years without a championship. In that stretch, George Steinbrenner fired 14 different managers.

He also, as we all know, tried to dig up dirt on his best player Dave Winfield, forcing him to be banned from Baseball.

The year before George was banned, the Yankees won 74 games. 74. It had be 4 years since they touched a 90 win season.

In the time that he was gone, Gene Michael, Bill Livesey, Brian Sabean and yes, later Brian Cashman, drafted, developed, and produced what we now know as the Yankees dynasty.

We also know that George tried to trade Derek Jeter the moment he returned, and Brian Cashman and Willie Randoloph had to practically throw themselves in front of a moving truck in order to stop him.

What most DONT know however, is that George fired Gene Michael, all of his scouts, and all of the architects of the 90s dynasty upon his return, and many within the organization said the dynasty died that day, before it even began. They all say that had George not been such an egomaniac, the Yankees could've gone on to dominate for much, much longer than they did - which is hard to imagine.

Since then, they have won one single championship in the past 25 years. They have not been able to recreate the genius of the architects who created what is now famously known as "The Yankee Way".

Hal has handed the reigns over to Brian Cashman, who back in the 90s - considered leaving the Yankees entirely or a UPS delivery job to hold him over while he went to law school, leaving baseball behind him.

His shouting matches with George, watching George force his way to close deals with players like Gary Sheffield screwing over a potential deal Cashman had in place for Vlad Guerrero, screaming arguments to protect prospects from being traded and so on, left Cashman scarred and allowed him to develop an arrogance in the wake of George's passing. Sustained excellence throughout the regular season has been coupled with a refusal to make trades that hurt but benefit the team in the immediate. That, along with a myriad of other mind bending decisions, has kept the Yankees from reaching the mountain top in this new era of NYY baseball.

At the end of the day, the Yankees won 20 championships before the Steinbrenner's took over.

Comparing eras is always relative - yes, the average fastball was 89 mph and Yogi Berra had side jobs working at Bowling Alleys, but that was the case for the rest of the league, and the Yankees found a way to win more than anyone else.

The Steinbrenner's have owned the team for 53 years. If you combine the title drought from '78-'96 and '09-'26 - that is 34 years combined of them overseeing championship droughts in NY.

Unacceptable.

reddit.com
u/ButterscotchPast5161 — 9 days ago
▲ 236 r/NYYankees

[Hoch] Aaron Boone said he is considering lineup changes for Game 3. The Yankees have scored two runs in the first two games of this ALDS.

x.com
u/TheTurtleShepard — 9 days ago
▲ 760 r/NYYankees

Why should Yankees fans believe they can win three straight games?

The Yankees have been here before. Can they repeat history?

Ben Rice is in the midst of a torrid postseason, and the last team to overcome an 0-2 deficit in a best-of-five series was New York in 2017.

More on what the Yankees have to do to pull off an ALDS comeback (read for free):
https://www.nytimes.com/athletic/7664530/2026/10/05/yankees-rays-game-2-takeaways-mlb-playoffs/?unlocked_article_code=1.GlE.Jcm8.iPE7zXOoYFOV&source=emp_shared_article&smid=url-share-ta

u/TheAthletic — 9 days ago

[Kirschner]: Why should fans believe Yankees can mount an 0-2 comeback in ALDS vs. Rays?

Before Game 1, Boone said he always hears that Tampa Bay doesn’t beat itself in games.

“No, they’ll give you things,” Boone said of the Rays. “The pressure they put on you is that they have other teams beat themselves.”

But through two games, the Rays have given the Yankees nothing other than providing endless laughs from their rivals’ fanbases. Now the Yankees are on the brink, in danger of ending this season the same way they’ve done so for the past 16 — without a championship.

nytimes.com
u/TheAthletic — 9 days ago
▲ 146 r/NYYankees

Don’t give up hope!

The series comes home tomorrow, and everyone that watches sports knows momentum swings can be huge! The team needs us fans now more than ever so don’t give up the faith and bring the house down Wednesday!!

Remember what happened with Trea Turner when the Phillies fans finally showed him some love, he actually played well!! We’ve got to give this team all our support!

reddit.com
u/mast3rcommand3r1234 — 9 days ago

[SNY Yankees] Aaron Boone explains why he elected to leave his left-handed bats in and not pinch-hit with a right-handed bat facing the Rays' lefties out of the bullpen

u/Recognition_Tricky — 9 days ago
▲ 129 r/NYYankees

Torre Made Pitchers Adjust. Boone Lets Them Settle In.

This is where I miss the Torre-era lineups.

They weren't literally L-R-L-R every night, but they had balance: lefties, righties and switch hitters throughout the order. A pitcher had to keep changing his approach from batter to batter.

With Boone, stacking lefties against a RH starter may win the platoon matchup on paper, but it can also let a pitcher settle into the same plan for several hitters in a row.

It also makes bullpen management easier. With the 3-batter minimum, L-R-L creates a matchup problem. L-L-L can make the decision obvious.

The other issue is this lineup doesn't grind enough at-bats.

In Game 1, the Yankees made Rasmussen throw 51 pitches through three innings.

Then he needed just:

9, 9, 14, 11 and 7 pitches over the next five.

That's way too comfortable in a playoff game.

The Torre teams had guys who could foul pitches off, work counts and make pitchers earn outs. Even when they weren't hitting, they could wear a starter down and get into the bullpen.

After the Game 1 offensive disaster, Boone should have made real lineup changes. It's the playoffs. You can't just keep running the same formula out there because the matchup looks good analytically.

Mix the handedness. Grind at-bats. Make pitchers adjust. Make the manager actually have to think about bullpen usage.

reddit.com
u/PM_ME_YUR_SALADS — 9 days ago
▲ 410 r/NYYankees

[SNY] "I'm not disappointed in our defense. I'm not disappointed in the offense. Really just disappointed in myself. That's baseball and those things are gonna happen. But I've got to be able to work through those. I wasn't able to do that today"

u/CicadaOk8885 — 9 days ago
▲ 105 r/NYYankees

[Kuty] For Yankees, a harsh reality after embarrassing Game 2 meltdown: ‘We beat ourselves’

Two batters later, Chisholm took a double-play feed from shortstop George Lombard Jr. and failed to look before throwing toward first base while falling to the ground. The throw went wide and skipped past first baseman Luis García Jr., allowing Díaz to score.

Boone defended the head-scratching decision.

“Probably best if you’re under control and you make the throw though it’s probably going to be bang-bang,” he said. “So I don’t necessarily have a problem with the throw. We’ve got to play catch. It’s the big leagues.”

Immediately after Chisholm’s error, an opposing scout in attendance sent a text to The Athletic: “There it is.” The remark was in reference to the Yankees’ reputation for making mistakes when the pressure is on.

Then, in the next at-bat, catcher Austin Wells set up too close to Liam Hicks, whose checked swing hit Wells’ glove for a catcher’s interference call, another costly error. It erased what would have been a called third strike.

In the fifth inning, it got worse. With one out, a runner on third base and Tampa Bay up two runs, the speedy Chandler Simpson hit a tapper to Lombard, who was playing in but couldn’t glove it. The run scored. The play was initially ruled an error before being changed to a fielder’s choice.

That led to Jonny DeLuca hitting a grounder at Lombard, whose throw to first sailed wide, pulling García off the bag. Then with runners on second and third after a stolen base, Richie Palacios hit a two-run single for a 5-1 Rays lead.

“It was just one of those games where things kind of compiled and stacked up on top of each other,” Lombard said.

Now, too much may have piled up on the Yankees, who also were victims of Wells’ crunch-time mental mistake, trying to stretch a double into a triple, in Game 1.

The Yankees will hope starting pitcher Max Fried and the crowd at Yankee Stadium can save them in Game 3 on Wednesday night.

But after that they would still have to win another two games against the Rays, including Game 5 back at Tropicana Field, where the Rays tied for the best home record in the majors.

u/TheAthletic — 9 days ago

[SNY Yankees] Max Fried confirmed that he plans to start tomorrow's Game 3 no matter what when asked directly

u/Recognition_Tricky — 9 days ago

[SNY Yankees] Matt Blake says Carlos Rodón could "potentially" be in play to come out of the bullpen in ALDS Game 3 (despite being lined up to start Game 4) and Gerrit Cole volunteered to pitch out of the bullpen yesterday in Game 2, but the Yankees weren't looking to go that route

u/Recognition_Tricky — 8 days ago

If the Yankees do not come back to win the WS, there will be players in the minors next season who will not have been born the last time the Yankees won it all.

This is William Alvarez, a top prospect from Cuba that is expected to sign with the Athletics on the international signing period opening date of January 15, 2027. Born December 22, 2009, he will be 17 years, 24 days old.

On that day, it will have been 17 years, 72 days since the Yankees won the WS (November 4, 2009). William Alvarez wasn't born for another 7 weeks. It's felt like a lifetime since we won.

-> For reference, Kevin Alvarez is the youngest active professional baseball player and No. 1 prospect in the Astros organization. He signed a contract on the 2025 January 15th opening at 17 years + 2 days old. He debuted that June for DSL Astros Blue at 17 years, 5 months and moved up to Low-A this April after being invited to Spring Training.

Note: There's a possibility that this doesn't happen, which is if the owner's push to increase the minimum age to 18 passes.

u/Pool_Breeze — 8 days ago