r/Nantucket

What are the pros and cons about living on Nantucket?

Abby of the trio here, my sister is planning on retiring soon and she’s thinking of retiring to Nantucket but to help her make a decision I wanted to ask all who live on the island what are the pros and cons of living on Nantucket? she already is aware there’s no Barnes & Noble, grocery stores are limited to a Stop n Shop as well local fish shops. Anything else to help her?

reddit.com
u/Gymtrio2025 — 2 days ago
▲ 33 r/Nantucket+1 crossposts

Help identifying this signature.

Hello, as the title says, I’m trying to identify this signature. Any help or guesses would very much be appreciated.

u/Capital-Nebula-777 — 2 days ago

Where can I get fashion tape?

Does anyone know of any stores selling fashion tape or similar product? It’s too late to order online so I need irl options on island please 🙏🏼

reddit.com
u/More-Honey-9345 — 1 day ago

Need to reserve a Hy-Line walk-on ferry ticket for mid-week ride?

Hi All,

Our group of six people would rather not pre-order RT walk-on tickets for the Hy-Line ferry, Hyannis to Nantucket, Tuesday, Sept 22. Is that a foolish move?

We plan to return to Hyannis on Friday, September 25.

Many thanks for your advice!

reddit.com
u/LinusPoindexter — 2 days ago

Have a boat and need a fishing partner?

Long shot here, but I will be on island from Wednesday until Monday the 24th and would love to get out and do some fishing while there but I am not really in a position to charter a boat, as it would only be me and the cost is too much to absorb.
That said, I would gladly throw some money into someone’s gas tank if they were headed out on a trip and wanted to let me join.
I’m in my mid 40s, have a good amount of experience on boats and have my own gear available so I won’t be a total leach; just looking to catch some blues for the first time in a long time.
Hit me up if that might appeal and we can discuss further.

reddit.com
u/Mykiss420 — 4 days ago

I am looking for this tote!

If you have one and would be willing to sell - please let me know! Thanks so much.

u/H3llsWindStaff — 4 days ago

Nantucket AirBnB SCAM - Shame on Airbnb!

My friend and her daughter were totally scammed by an AirBnB listing on Nantucket last weekend. It was advertised as a separate apartment, but the front door, kitchen, small common area and bathroom were SHARED with two other bedrooms. To make matters worse, these were grown men who work at the restaurant owned by the AirBnB host. This is totally misleading and a complete lie and horrifically UNSAFE for a woman and her teenage daughter.

AirBnB was contacted and they refunded the money, but they took no other responsibility and blamed the owner (who blamed AirBnB) and did not work to help them find a place to stay even though they were completely STRANDED. The entire island was SOLD OUT (this happens on Saturday nights in August on Nantucket) and they ended up staying in a neighbor's extra apartment that took pity on them standing on the side of the road trying to find a place to stay. Thank God there are kind, caring people out there!

The address of the scam is 32 Appleton Road on Nantucket. Do NOT stay there. Link to the listing is below.

https://www.airbnb.com/rooms/1734192908499713158?check_in=2026-08-18&check_out=2026-08-20&guests=1&adults=2&s=67&unique_share_id=da675e27-926f-4291-877c-607de6ae97e7

u/Airbnb www.airbnb.com

airbnb.com
u/Serious-Intention425 — 6 days ago

Just curious; serving wages

Curious what servers make at places like Cru, Straight Wharf, Galley, etc from June-Sept. anyone previously work there or know someone and what they made?

reddit.com
u/Adventurous_Rent4719 — 5 days ago

Financial Analysis of “No Influencers”

One of my favorite YouTube channels posted a THOROUGH breakdown of the financial culture of influencers. This was pillared by the drama going on in Nantucket this summer with Paige Lorenze.

Great listen/watch if you’re interested.

youtu.be
u/Last_slice — 5 days ago

Best Beach for Sunset

Hi - I’m in town for a solo trip and would like to pick-up dinner, bike to one of the beaches, eat dinner, read my kindle and watch the sunset. I’m staying in downtown.

Any recs on the best beach to do this? TIA!

reddit.com
u/Impressive_Tone4144 — 7 days ago

Best places to watch Red Sox in public on island?

Going to be there in a couple weekends when the Sox play the Yankees 4x. Would love to know some good spots, popular or hidden, to watch w the public!

reddit.com
u/EconomicsWestern7355 — 6 days ago

Tickets for the Fray Monday night

Looking to grab 2 tickets for the fray Monday at the muse, willing to pay above purchase price if able to transfer!

reddit.com
u/Aerowonder — 6 days ago

Lunch

Would love a recommendation for lunch on the island. It's been a few years since I have visited . We like all foods - looking for quality and no chaos! Thanks !

reddit.com
u/Poodlegirlie — 9 days ago

Cheap overnight stay after Motion City Soundtrack concert September 24th?

Hey everyone, I want to go to Nantucket for the Motion City Soundtrack show at The Muse on September 24th. AFAIK The last ferry back to Hyannis leaves at 9:20 PM and the concert is at 9:30. there is a 6:30 ferry the next morning, so I need to find somewhere to crash for just a few hours afterward, nothing fancy, just somewhere to sleep cheaply until I can catch that early ferry.

I've looked at hotels and Airbnbs and they're all $300 plus. I would take a hostel bunk, shared room, even a couch if someone had one available. Are there any budget lodging options on the island I'm missing? there doesn't appear to be any campgrounds, and you can't camp on the public land. do any locals have suggestions for how to handle situations like this?

reddit.com
u/Freduccine — 8 days ago

Class of '07 reunion?

There was no 10th, and no word on the 20th. I moved a while ago, and I may like to visit the island next year... would make sense to time it around this. Anyone privy?

reddit.com
u/bruh_what_even_tho — 8 days ago

Grocery delivery service on the island

Does anyone have recommendations for grocery delivery on the island. We rent our place out when we’re not there and would love to offer our guests a service to get groceries and put them away in the kitchen before they arrive.

reddit.com
u/Last_slice — 7 days ago

The Muse - QuinnXCII

Hi all! Making the trip to the island for a QuinnXCII concert at The Muse this weekend and not sure what to expect! The venue looks quite small, concert is at 10, doors open at 8. Im the kind of person that wants to be right at the front and will arrive as early as necessary to do so. What time do you think is necessary to arrive to be sure I'm at the front? We are staying walking distance from the venue which makes things easier. What's the bathroom situation? What's the after concert vibe/are there nearby bars that the artists tend to frequent post concert? Thanks for any info, excited to see everyone who goes!!

reddit.com
u/chrisprattsguineapig — 8 days ago
▲ 4 r/Nantucket+1 crossposts

Anyone know the berry??

These grow behind my office every August. Always wondered if it was good pickings, or should I leave them for the deer?

u/Current-Television23 — 8 days ago