r/ONETREEHILL

None of them were particularly amazing to me. All of them were either bad or boring imo. Idk what it is, but I didn’t care for any of her pairings on the show.

Leyton and Naley were both epic romances, and I feel like they tried to do that for Brooke by bringing in Julian, but it just doesn’t hit the same for me.

-Brooke and Lucas: The actors had great chemistry in the first three seasons, but it was always obvious that Lucas was meant to be with Peyton. Him and Brooke were destined for failure from the start.

-Brooke and Felix: No explanation needed. 🤮

-Brooke and Nick: Again, not much to explain. 🤮

-Brooke and Chase: He was nice, but boring. They just didn’t have any chemistry imo. It wasn’t there.

-Brooke and Owen: There was potential, but it was so short lived and they moved on from them quickly.

-Brooke and Julian: I know a lot of people loved them together because he gave Brooke everything she ever wanted, and I love that for her, but they just didn’t have the same spark as the other main ships.

So I’ve never thought Karen was a saint or anything but I’ve also never thought her to be this like ultra bad parent and not just because there’s a lot of bad parents in the show.

Where I’m confused is where is all this sudden Karen hate I see coming from??? Sure, she’s not perfect but not a single one of them is. Missing Lucas’ game? Of course a misstep but she makes it up. Basically saying Keith dying was Lucas’ fault? Worst thing she’s ever done and it was driven by extreme grief (not that it’s right ofc)

I’m seeing being saying she’s a secret villain and I fear everyone has lost their minds.