Stuck between YouTube Kids and unrestricted YouTube — what are parents doing?
We’re hitting an awkward transition point with YouTube and I’m curious what other parents are realistically doing.
My son is heavily into gaming and wants to watch specific streamers/creators that are completely unavailable on YouTube Kids. The “older kids” YT Kids setting honestly still seems very filtered/random and doesn’t really reflect the actual gaming ecosystem kids his age are interested in.
At the same time, unrestricted YouTube obviously comes with concerns around algorithm drift, shorts rabbit holes, inappropriate content etc.
To complicate things further, in Australia we’re now stuck in a weird position where under-16s are prevented from signing into normal YouTube accounts in a way that allows us to actually apply supervision/content controls properly.
There also seems to be some kind of Google/Family Link DOB glitch where the account is recognised as under 16 for YouTube access restrictions, but not in a way that lets us apply supervised under-16 settings consistently.
So at the moment our practical options seem to be:
- ban YouTube entirely,
or
- allow unrestricted/open YouTube and monitor manually.
We do actively monitor/check history and talk about internet navigation with him, but it would honestly be nice to have some middle-ground content restrictions available rather than either “YouTube Kids only” or “completely unrestricted.”
I’m not really interested in “ban YouTube completely forever” because:
- it’s a huge part of gaming/social culture now,
- he mainly wants specific creators,
- and I suspect long-term navigation/media literacy matters more than pretending the platform doesn’t exist.
What are other parents actually doing for:
- gamer kids,
- creator/streamer watching,
- supervised YouTube,
- history review,
- algorithm management,
- and teaching kids how to navigate the platform safely?
Especially interested in approaches that are more nuanced than either:
- “full unrestricted access”
or
- “absolutely no YouTube ever.”