r/RedSonja

What do you all think?

https://preview.redd.it/v71wuvgrwcdh1.png?width=1195&format=png&auto=webp&s=2d49ea3ef925aed731be15464fd90fbaae685bf8

Here is an analysis of the reception of Red Sonja movie, based on IMDb score, currently set at 4.6. There are only about 9K reviews, I would say a low number suggesting that it has been so far ignored by most users.

1-Star Votes (Lowest score): ~12% of all total votes. This chunk represents the baseline of the aggressive backlash. These are often comic purists mostly loyal to the original classic setup from Marvel, frustrated by the massive narrative deviations, or more modern fans not recognising critical elements of the lore.

4-to-6-Star Votes: ~50% Mostly casual fantasy viewers stumbling across the film on digital platforms and approaching it without much expectations and limited knowledge of the lore. They view it as a harmless, early-2000s-style direct-to-video b-movie. They recognize the clear budget constraints, uneven CGI, and predictable and inconsistent plot, but find the practical stunt work and the cast (mostly Matilda Lutz’s) performance to be passable or even worthy of praise.

10-Star Votes (Highest score): ~5.5% of all voters. This group is interesting because it appears split in two unequal subgroups:

• ~15% of comic loyals: Mostly Gail Simone's fans. Simone’s run famously recontextualized Sonja's origin away from the classic lore, and she is listed as executive producer. Her introduced female empowered vision strongly inspired the movie adaptation, and some 10-star reviewers are fans defending this specific version of the lore.
• ~85% of Anti-Review-Bombing Force (The "Culture Warriors"): These are internet users who likely have never read a Red Sonja comic. They score the movie a 10 mostly as a defensive reaction to counter what they perceive as "toxic review-bombing" by old-school purists or anti-progressive commentators.