Think Your Income Tax Is ₹0 Because You Earn Under ₹12 Lakh? There Are 5 Situations Where It Isn't.
Tax filing season is here.
And if there's one thing we've learned answering questions on this subreddit every day, it's this:
Most people don't make mistakes because taxes are complicated.
They make mistakes because they assume one rule applies to everything.
Here are 5 tax myths that keep showing up.
(1) "My income is below ₹12 lakh. So I don't have to pay tax."
Not always.
The ₹12 lakh rebate only applies to income taxed using slabs like:
- Salary
- Pension
- Bank interest
It doesn't apply to income taxed separately, such as:
- Short-term capital gains (STCG)
- Long-term capital gains (LTCG)
Example:
- Salary: ₹11.4 lakh
- Profit from selling shares within a year (STCG): ₹60,000
- Total income: ₹12 lakh
Many people expect ₹0 tax.
Reality:
- Salary → rebate applies → ₹0 tax
- STCG → taxed separately at 20%
You still pay tax on the ₹60,000.
(2) "I only made ₹500 profit from stocks. Surely I can still use ITR-1?"
No.
The amount doesn't matter.
Even ₹1 of Short-Term Capital Gain means you move from ITR-1 to ITR-2.
On the other hand...
If you only sold stocks or equity mutual funds after one year and your LTCG is below ₹1.25 lakh (with no losses to carry forward), you can now use ITR-1.
That's a new change this filing season.
(3) "I own US stocks, but they're worth almost nothing."
Still matters. If you hold:
- Foreign shares
- RSUs
- A foreign bank account
ITR-1 is no longer available. The value doesn't matter.
The fact that you own them does.
(4) "Old vs New tax regime changes everything."
Not really. Changing your tax regime mostly changes how salary-type income gets taxed.
Capital gains don't suddenly become tax-free because you picked a different regime.
Whether you're in Old or New:
- STCG keeps its own tax rate.
- LTCG keeps its own tax rate.
Changing regimes doesn't change that.
(5) "Which ITR form should I actually file?"
Here's the simplified version.
| If you have... | Usually file... |
|---|---|
| Salary + interest | ITR-1 |
| Salary + LTCG (listed shares/equity MF) up to ₹1.25L | ITR-1 |
| Any STCG | ITR-2 |
| Foreign shares / RSUs | ITR-2 |
| Business income (presumptive) | ITR-4 |
| F&O / Intraday / Business / Professional income | ITR-3 |
(Assuming no special situations like audit requirements.)
The One Thing To Remember
Think of your income as sitting in different buckets.
- Salary, pension and bank interest follow one set of rules.
- Capital gains follow another.
- Business income follows another.
Once you stop mixing those buckets together, most tax confusion disappears.
Quick Reality Check
Before filing, ask yourself these four questions:
- Did I sell any shares or mutual funds this year?
- Do I own any foreign shares or RSUs?
- Did I trade F&O or intraday?
- Am I choosing my ITR form because "that's what I filed last year"?
If any answer is yes, it's worth double-checking before submitting your return.
💬 Let's test this.
Comment your income mix like this:
Salary ₹9L + FD interest ₹30k + Equity MF LTCG ₹70k
or
Salary ₹14L + STCG ₹18k
we'll tell you which ITR form usually applies.
Still confused with Tax Regimes?
Check out - Old vs New Tax Regime: Which Is Better For You?
Disclaimer: This is educational content and not a tax or financial advice.