EVO-X3 vs MS-S1 MAX: Which is the better choice?
Hi everyone, I am considering buying either the EVO-X3 or the MS-S1 MAX for local AI usage (e.g. Qwen3.8-27B or MoE models like Gemma 4 26B A4B or Qwen3.8-Flash-Next). I am currently running a Dell R720 with 128GB of RAM and two NVIDIA P40s on Linux (Debian), but this platform is getting more and more difficult to manage and maintain.
My budget is around €4,000 and I am aware of the fact that the Strix Halo platform is limited, mainly by its memory bandwidth. I could buy a lot of cloud AI credits but prefer to run LLMs locally.
The trade-offs in the EU/Germany offers I'm considering are:
GMKtec EVO-X3 (~€3,700): 4TB SSD, native OCuLink and two PCIe 4.0 x4 M.2 slots. Downsides: only 2.5GbE, one USB4 port and less convenient chassis access.
MINISFORUM MS-S1 MAX (~€4,000): 2TB SSD, dual 10GbE, USB4 80Gbps, accessible chassis and internal PCIe expansion. Downsides: higher price and second M.2 limited to x1. The expansion slot is electrically Gen4 x4, so OCuLink might be added later on.
What are important considerations when comparing the EVO-X3 and the MS-S1 MAX? How are stability, sustained performance, fan noise and support? Would you buy the same machine again?