r/ismydisneypinfake

Picked these up with board / guest trades an I’m questioning.

I’m more confident in tinkerbell than other two.

My wife got these as free gifts and I want to make sure before adding them to my traders.

Stitch with the pineapple sunglasses doesn’t have the FAC number on the back, so I’m thinking that’s a fake.

The Angel pins: I had read online that this set had some quality control issues with the Mickey waffle pattern having a slight border on one side, but it’s the diamond Mickey head that is making me think they might be fake. It’s not nearly as smooth as they usually are and I can feel each of the stones.

Anyone have any insight?

Is anyone able to tell from the pictures if this Eve is authentic? Real pic on the left.

Thank you

I won these on a pin auction. This auction site is supposed to be only authentic pins. I thought the Chewy looked weird but it was good enough for a $5 trader. I got to looking at them comparing photos online and I'm thinking these are all faked. Pin and Pop have a warning that they have been faked. I wanted some opinions from others who know more than me before I ask for my money back. Thank you in advance!!

Just got back from DW and traded a little bit while there; mostly pinboards.

i assume the peter pan one is absolutely fake. but the rest i have no clue! close up pictures as well!

The "Tales" looks more orange than yellow so I'm wondering if that means it's fake

I bought this getting really excited because it was a good price but then I realized it might have been a little too good to be true bc the seller looked sketchy. Does it look fake? I bought him for 39 and change

So I bought a couple mystery bags and this caught my eye on a pin board. Aware there is tons and tons of fakes floating about. This was found on a resorts DVC board first thing in the morning. What do we think, real or not?

It came in a little plastic baggie got this from a big time whatnot seller

Im seeing warnings on pin sites saying this is being counterfeited but I know how tricky paris pins can be sometimes. The pin itself seems smaller than id expect..does anyone have a real one and could share photos for comparison?

I just purchased this pin from eBay and I’m 99% sure it’s fake. There are bubbles and the color is very yellow, but I don’t have any real WDI pins to compare so I’m here looking to get internet stranger validation lol.

Also, how would you approach the seller? Would you leave public negative feedback? Request a refund? Just write it off as part of the risk of online/ebay purchases? (I’ll probably just write it off and craft this into a magnet or ornament)

TIA

UPDATE nobody asked for…

I messaged the seller and requested a refund. The seller directed me to submit a return request and to select “changed mind” as the reason. That gave me pause, google ai tells me that this selection shifts the cost of the return from seller to buyer. I double checked the sellers policies and their store states the seller will pay for return shipping. I have not gotten a return shipping label of money back yet. But thank you to everyone who weighed in. I appreciate the assist.

I’ve been doing a good bit of trading and Im just curious if anyone knows which of these are real and which are fake!

i’ve never seen this real or fake but i got it in trivia so im not sure! thanks for looking :)

i am pretty good at spotting fake pins but these were ones I was unsure about but still picked up from boards. they all feel good, the I don’t bite Mickey feels a bit thin but don’t know if that’s usual per the pin. the goofy ticket, Donald street, and car are all common fakes, but these seem much better then what I typically see

I don’t remember how much I paid but I got this from EBay a couple of years ago when I first got into pins. I have a feeling it’s fake but I wanted to get your guy’s opinions.