r/musicology

Academic research on artistic authenticity in the AI world
▲ 8 r/musicology+5 crossposts

Academic research on artistic authenticity in the AI world

Hi there! I'm a musician and I'm doing a research on the theme of the artistic authenticity in the AI world. To gather some useful informations I could use your help by submitting to you a survey. If you can find the time to answer some multiple choice questions I would really appreciate it! (It's really short, 3 minutes max) Thanks!

https://forms.gle/nEfcCKPzPfJ9qgWs7

u/Worried-Incident-145 — 9 days ago
▲ 4 r/musicology+1 crossposts

Student Survey about Forensic Musicology

Greetings. I am a faculty member doing academic research about best practices for teaching courses about music and the law generally and forensic musicology specifically. If you have taken a course of any kind at the intersection of music and law I would greatly appreciate it if you would take a few moments to fill it out. Thank you!

https://forms.cloud.microsoft/Pages/ResponsePage.aspx?id=W9229i_wGkSZoBYqxQYL0jbrJjuo81RFrM9cJH301RJUMzc5TjVBWExTWEhMU0NUUlVXMEI1VlM4NS4u

reddit.com
u/Music-Law — 8 days ago
▲ 4 r/musicology+3 crossposts

Which opera has this character?

Can anyone recall which lesser known opera by a better known composer has a character named Tigrana or something like that?

reddit.com
u/AnjaMalena — 9 days ago
▲ 5 r/musicology+1 crossposts

Is this plagiarism?

Recently one of my favorite artists is being sued for sounding similar to a demo released, the reason that person gave was because both songs are written in 4/4 time and the key of B♭ minor, featuring a similar 31-note melodic sequence across approximately eight bars. Even though it’s one picture and it’s hard to tell right now but does anyone know if this can be classified as plagiarism

u/Ill_Luck986 — 11 days ago
▲ 12 r/musicology+1 crossposts

While there are numerous musical genres that arose in the past century, classical music seems to be only subdivided by form or period: did musical genres exist before the 1900s the way they exist now?

The same question would be interested to be analysed also in terms of spaciality and not only temporality: we mostly think of music from a western/US perspective, as most of the genres we listen to nowadays originated there, while everything else gets bundled under World/Folk music, so it feels that a genre such as "African music" exists in itself without the possibility of as many layers of subdivision. Do we apply to past music the same treatment?

reddit.com
u/a_simple_human — 9 days ago
▲ 15 r/musicology+2 crossposts

Are shorter attention spans changing the way we experience music?

I'm thinking about how much our attention spans are changing.

With short videos, endless scrolling, rapid dopamine bursts, and algorithms constantly presenting us with something new, I feel it's becoming increasingly difficult for people to engage deeply with music.

Sometimes songs are treated like fast-paced content. If the chorus doesn't come fast enough, people skip it. If an album requires patience, many people don't dedicate time to it.

Do you think this is changing the way we listen to music?

Are we losing our ability to appreciate slow, emotional, flawed, or complex music?

And do you think AI-generated music could make this even worse by creating even more endless background content?

reddit.com
u/chainofchance — 12 days ago
▲ 60 r/musicology+2 crossposts

Storyville closed in November 1917. Within five years, the music had recoded itself in three cities. A migration map worth arguing about.

The Department of the Navy pressured New Orleans to shut down the red-light district where most of the working musicians were employed. Mayor Behrman complied. November 12, 1917, the district closed. The players scattered.
Within five years:
• King Oliver in Chicago, Lincoln Gardens, recording for Gennett (1923).
• Sidney Bechet in New York with Will Marion Cook’s Southern Syncopated Orchestra, then London, then Paris (1919 onward). He played for King George V before he was thirty.
• Jelly Roll Morton in Chicago, recording for Gennett and Paramount (early ‘20s; he’d left NOLA earlier).
• Bunk Johnson out of music until the 1940s rediscovery.
• Buddy Bolden already in the East Louisiana State Hospital since 1907 — he never left it.
The first record sold as jazz — the Original Dixieland Jass Band’s “Livery Stable Blues” — was cut in February 1917 in New York, before Storyville closed, by white New Orleans musicians who’d already migrated.
Two questions:
1. How much of what we call the “Chicago era” is really just New Orleans players who happened to find a recording infrastructure in the city the Illinois Central terminated in?
2. Is there a good treatment of Bechet’s London/Paris years? The Sidney Bechet who came back to the U.S. in the 1920s had played for the King of England. The continental detour seems undertheorized in American jazz writing.
[Disclosure] Working on a podcast about American music history — happy to point if the mods are good with it. Mostly here for the conversation.

reddit.com
u/YoPapaYo42 — 13 days ago

Why do instruments that end in “horn” (e.g. French horn, English horn, and basset horn) tend to be in the key of F?

Basically what the title says. Is there any history behind why this might be the case or is this a coincidence? I tried using Google but none of the results were relevant to what I was asking. I figured if anyone knew the answer to this question, they’d probably be on this subreddit. TIA!

reddit.com
u/ThisisWaffle_ — 10 days ago
▲ 1 r/musicology+1 crossposts

What does this song draw from? English pub music and/or English traditionals perhaps?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3XHWuU_1A7g

The Creation - If I Stay Too Long

I'm trying to figure out how or if I can find more music like this. To me, my best guess is that this draws more from some sort of English acapella singing - like traditionals or pub songs. I'm not really hearing a big blues or soul or other african american influence, but I could be wrong. To be extra clear, I especially mean in terms of the chords and melody and harmonies - not instrumentation, for example. Any thoughts? Thanks in advance!

u/SnooNine — 13 days ago