r/ratemycommanders

Deck 1: Yurlok Mana Drain(low win rate but peak table chaos)

Deck 2: Maha -1/-1s and toxic win con/Gary as alt commander with some blue card subs

Deck 3: The Master Multiplied(lots of old cards like Sneak Attack to cheat out myriad creatures for one red and then spam copies when playing with a big table)

Deck 4: My personal favorite. Not the usual thopter spam breya, instead I went with a treasure/clue/food engine and then use those to do essentially anything I want with breya lol

Sidar Jabari of Zhalfir: Knight Tribal
Orah, Skyclave Hierophant: Cleric Tribal
Mm’menon The Right Hand: Artifacts

Knights have had the most work, followed by Clerics, and Artifacts is a brand new one for me

Hey all,
I always feel like the problem in games with my playgroup. All my decks are bracket 3 or lower and I feel like it’s because they don’t play enough mass removal or single target. Also taking fun upgrade suggestions.
Deck list for each deck.

Cloud: https://moxfield.com/decks/qluSjy6QZUSvIT7FNoL0Dw

Howler: https://moxfield.com/decks/adtDm0t8xk2QU2W\_AxLwPQ

Marchesa: https://moxfield.com/decks/hjxsc-KGD02NYtmTmHEpgA

Mothman: https://moxfield.com/decks/vTVLiWM8CkKMusq7s75VRQ

Morcant: https://moxfield.com/decks/TNLSSGrxQ0mWuq9irAkrNw

I love Final Fantasy VIII and have ever since the Pizza Hut demo discs that came out when they released the original Stuffed Crust pizza. I'm working on a project where I have decks for every Final Fantasy VIII character who got a card; Cid and the Edea from the gift box set are still in the works.

Squall is B3, and runs a pseudo-Voltron combat Aristocrats deck built around recursion loops to control the board and build advantage. Win cons are either Commander damage or establishing [[Sun Titan]] combo loops into [[Debt to the Deathless]]/[[Exsanguinate]].

Quistis is B3 Mill, designed to turbo big mana so I can play whatever massive impact instants and sorceries I force my opponents to put in their graveyards. No Bruvac to keep her in B3, wins either by milling my opponents out or by hitting something spicy in their graveyards that create strange and interesting lines. Probably my most fun deck, and easily the one I have to think with the most.

Rinoa is B2 Humans. Her role as the commander is just to be there on curve after the table gets wiped, because she and the Angelo token she creates are a good way to add pressure on a decimated board. Otherwise she just sits in the CZ and the deck just does Humans things.

Zell is B2 Landfall, and is based around the red Landfall pingers to produce incremental value on each drop and make the game go faster. Wins by forcing people's shields down with things like the Goad from [[Disrupt Decorum]] or [[Geode Rager]], or combat loops with [[Moraug, Fist of Akoum]].

Ultimecia is B4 Time Kompression Tribal. And I will say, this is not a good B4 deck. The goal is building big mana to push out Eldrazi and extra turn spells because Ultimecia's whole thing from FF8 is compressing past, present, and future into a condensed and overlapping state of perpetual stasis where temporally-bound beings cannot exist or function. It's built for flavor rather than competitive function, but can turn chain-lock to pick up the W.

Seifer is a B3 Punisher effect deck, based around asking "What are the filthiest things I can do with instants and sorceries cast from the bin for 3 CMC or less when he hits?" The deck could function as a B2, but one of the best answers I found to that question was "Well... [[Jeska's Will]] is 2R." The deck is capable of accidentally Storming out with Rituals and the like.

So... can I sit down with y'all?

Almost all Bracket 3 except Klothys and Saheeli (Bracket 2) :) could I sit at your table ?

Emperor B2

Killian B3

Niv B3

Firja B2
Talion B3

I’ve been collecting for a few years and semi brewing decks for a while but actually haven’t had a lot of play experience. These are the decks I’ve built though

Planning on 2 more mono colored decks, just no idea who

Bruna: Boardwipe then reanimate your way to victory. Get excited if you manage to get [[Gisela, the Broken Blade]] out.

Cynette: Commons and uncommons only. Blink, clone, and bounce to try to slow the game down long enough for your jellyfish to whittle away your opponent's hp.

Volrath: Retro border only deck. Turn fatties into combat tricks and hope you can give Volrath shadow or swamp walk long enough to get a kill.

Norin: abuse etb triggers like every other Norin deck. If that isn't working out try to put a sticker on him while you wait for death.

Sauron: Okay, you got me. I haven't made this yet but it's my next project and I wanted to complete the cycle

All of my decks are aimed for b3

Been playing for several months now and all decks are either bracket 2 or 3 with the exception with one that is pure jank in bracket 1 and the last one in progress (making into Bracket 2)

Y'shtola pillowfort lifegain/drain Bracket 3

Mog token burn bracket 3

Gamer voltron/attractions bracket 2

Berta X-spells/token/Hydras bracket 3

Twins voltron/spellslinger bracket 2

Grismold grouphug/voltron bracket 2

Satya aggro burn bracket 3

Saheeli artifact combo bracket 3

Riku modal/spellslinger/voltron bracket 2

Flubs Landfall/manifest(Cloak/morph) bracket 3

Ares aggro bracket 2

Rex Nebula vehicle explosions bracket 1

Breya artifact token burn bracket 3

Firja spellslinger bracket 2

Queen token pillowfort bracket 2

Ulasht (haven't decided) bracket 2

I'll link any deck from mana box if requested except for Ulasht (not fully built)

The first two are partners of a an angel and cleric com at damage deck, skittles is voltron with a speed subtheme, Grist is self-mill Aristocrats, Dalakos is mill, Inalla is a bracket 2 using tiny cards and giant comander, Black walts no. 3 is my most recent deck and runs all the black wizards and lots of instants and artifacts

I started playing about 6 months ago. I really haven’t played any live matches, except against myself. I know was told Myrel and Lathril would make me targets. After using them as commanders on MTG Arena, I can see why. Sometimes I hate myself when I am using them lol

Here are my commanders so far. Let me know what you think.