r/ratemycommanders

Image 1 — Can I play?
Image 2 — Can I play?
Image 3 — Can I play?
Image 4 — Can I play?
Image 5 — Can I play?

Can I play?

Arcanis: Untap synergies / control.

Azusa: Nonbasic lands tribute.

Haakon: Knights tribal.

Angus Mackenzie: Divine Intervention rush.

Korvold: Lame sacrifice stuff (he's been more boring to play than I thought; probably converting to Sek'kuar)

u/Majestic_Sweet_5472 — 5 hours ago

Lemme sit?

Currently working through the 32 deck commander challenge, so I have a lot of options for any pod :)

Bello, Bard of the Brambles:

https://archidekt.com/decks/12823215/bello_bramblin_bard

Leori, Spark Touched Hunter:

https://archidekt.com/decks/22620968/leori_touchin_sparks

The Wandering Minstrel:

https://archidekt.com/decks/21685562/wandering_minstrel

Slinza, The Spiked Stampede:

https://archidekt.com/decks/20709150/slinza_fight_club

Narci, Fable Singer:

https://archidekt.com/decks/11973865/narci_pain_bringer

Edit: added a few deck links I didn't passport yet, to show they are not all just women Q.Q

u/Maenven — 21 hours ago

Me like edh

Fumulus is my current favorite deck. It's aristocrats with as many things like grave pact as I could fit and also a couple big mana spells like exsanguinate as a treat. I wasnt going to, but i kept finding myself accidentally ending up with like 30+ mana.

Shu yun- play cheap voltron spells that replace themselves and take out one person (then die because you spent all your gas and the other 2 players are scared youre going to do it again.

Wilhelm- zombies

Ghen- curses and enchantments that want to be sacrificed for profit as well as some "good stuff"

u/theentiregoonsquad — 14 hours ago

Current Commander Lineup (and Their Vibes)

Would any of these earn a spot at your table?

Never played in a bracket so current brackets might be wrong.

u/SirXin — 19 hours ago

If you had to keep 4 of these, Which ones would you keep?

Looking to go down a couple decks. Just curious to see what people think and see if that helps me think it through a bit.

u/Ok_Reach_7271 — 24 hours ago

Am I allowed at the table? I'll bring snacks

Here is a small sample of the commanders I enjoy using the most when I play, what do you think?

u/404_DogeNotFound — 23 hours ago

My collection of idiots

Been playing for around 2.5 years now, after getting introduced on a trip with some friends. I'm a little addicted. I mostly build precons, but I have Proxies for Bracket 3 play (I'm a student so I'm broke af). Can I have a seat?

u/Individual_Plane758 — 22 hours ago

Bracket 2 or 3? Rate my commanders, can I sit with yall?

I've been playing for 12ish years, constantly rotating through commanders and making it a point to try new things out. Also, I'm a firm believer that commander is Casual Format and refuse to make my decks way too competitive. If I feel like I win too easily, I make adjustments, so it's more fun for the table. Idk, it's my style, so I think most of these guys are bracket 2 (Disclaimer my Raffine deck has Thassa's Oracle, but I swap it out from time to time).

And I also understand that bracket 3 is not competitive edh. But I've been seeing what some of you consider bracket 3 and its definitely more powerful then I initially thought.

Before you might think Necrobloom, Teval, Zurgo is edhrec slop just gotta say my first constructed block where I played Standard was Khans of Tarkir so when dragonstorm came out I went all out, got some precons and it was the inspiration for my Galazeth, Teval and Zurgo decks. I played a lot of Sultai Whip, so when Teval came out, I fell in love ❤️. And well my Necrobloom is just a pile of good fun landfall cards.

Also, universes beyond commanders? Idk, they dont really scratch my itch, but good cards

Here's the lists, I truly dont know if they are mostly bracket 2 or 3? If you want you can let me know

https://archidekt.com/decks/13295355/teval\_recursion\_lands

https://archidekt.com/decks/19849106/zurgo\_stormrender

https://archidekt.com/decks/19726315/raffine\_2026\_discard\_reanimator\_and\_drawing

https://archidekt.com/decks/19104352/galazeth\_dragons\_and\_artifacts

https://archidekt.com/decks/19267106/necrobloom\_dredge\_reanimator

https://archidekt.com/decks/22774980/klothys\_group\_slug

https://archidekt.com/decks/22794912/gonti\_politics

I love commanders with built-in card advantage. What do you think about my line-up?

In order of my (current) most favourite to least favourite.

u/No-Lie3960 — 1 day ago

36 deck challenge list

Almost done with it! Still working out some of the monocolors, simic, and Gruul as well as the last four color I need.

u/FrostBitezero17 — 1 day ago

Can I have a seat at your table? I enjoy some magic of all levels!

I enjoy some higher power decks. But these are the main decks I enjoy and bring with me for some diverse and fun magic. I hope i csn have another seat after our game!

u/LambKaiser — 2 days ago