r/theroamingdead

▲ 2 r/theroamingdead+2 crossposts

The walking dead before and after the review bomb

Twd might not be the best after s8/9(those who know get why). Im on my 3rd rewatch after not seeing the show for a while and i can say the show doesnt deserve the ratings it had

u/AggressiveStill1376 — 8 days ago

What if TWD was set in the 1960s?

Robert Kirkman has said he was heavily inspired by Romero's work. And Night of the Living Dead came out in 1968, right at the peak of one of the most turbulent decades in American history. That's not a coincidence. So here's a question I can't stop thinking about: what if TWD actually took place then?

TWD has never really been about zombies. It's about what happens to people when the system collapses.

And in 1960s America, the system was already collapsing.

The Civil Rights Movement. Vietnam. The assassinations of JFK and MLK. A government that had been lying to its own people for years. Society was already fracturing before any zombie ever showed up. The dead rising would just be the final push on a door that was already open.

Romero understood this. Night of the Living Dead was never just a horror movie, it was a statement about race, fear, and what America actually looked like underneath the surface. TWD set in the 60s feels like a natural continuation of that idea.

Rick Grimes

Rick is 28 years old in 1968. A small-town Georgia cop who genuinely believes in the law, not from experience, but from idealism. He never went to Vietnam. A medical exemption kept him home.

That's his hidden wound. He watched other men go and come back broken while he stayed safe behind a badge. Becoming a cop was his way of convincing himself he was still doing something meaningful.

When the apocalypse begins, his central question isn't how to survive. It's: "who am I without the system I believed in?"

His arc is slow and painful. Every hard decision he makes, every line he crosses, he's gradually becoming something he wouldn't have recognized at the start. The moment he realizes it is the most devastating moment in the entire story.

Shane Walsh

Shane went to Vietnam. He saw things that rewired him completely. Violence became instinct. Trust became a liability. He came back ready for the worst at all times.

In the apocalypse, he adapts faster than anyone, because in many ways, he never left the last one.

This is what makes his collapse so much more tragic than in the original series. He's not just a jealous friend losing his grip. He's a man who survived one apocalypse only to find himself in another, slowly realizing the two were never that different.

Shane looks at Rick and sees someone who understands nothing.

Rick looks at Shane and sees his best friend disappearing.

Both of them are right.

The Governor and Woodbury

Philip Blake was a small-town Georgia politician before everything collapsed. Respectable. Church-going. The kind of man who shook hands at every county fair and made sure things stayed exactly the way they were, quietly, systematically, and always within the law.

The apocalypse didn't change him. It freed him.

Woodbury isn't just a dictatorship. It's a Southern town that simply refused to change, a community where the old hierarchies survived because someone made sure they did, wrapped in the language of order and safety.

Perhaps the most unsettling thing about Woodbury is that many of its residents know, on some level, what it really is. And they stay anyway. Because it feels stable. Because it feels familiar.

There's something in that dynamic that echoes how a lot of Americans experienced the official version of events during the Vietnam era, a carefully managed reality that felt safer than the truth.

The conflict between Rick and the Governor was never just hero versus villain. It's two versions of America that have always been at war with each other.

Morgan

Morgan wasn't only a father trying to protect his son. He was a Civil Rights activist. He marched. He got arrested. He got beaten. He gave years of his life to a cause he believed would build something better.

The apocalypse didn't just take his son. It erased the future he was fighting toward. Every sacrifice, every scar, every night in a jail cell, for a world that no longer exists.

That's a different kind of broken. And it makes his isolation feel less like madness and more like grief for something most people never even knew they lost.

I don't think this would just be The Walking Dead with old cars and vintage music.

I think moving the story to the 1960s changes what every major character represents. The apocalypse stops being just the collapse of civilization and becomes a mirror for a country that was already struggling with itself.

It feels less like a different setting, and more like a different way of understanding The Walking Dead.

reddit.com
u/AnonymousAleen — 11 days ago