u/Accomplished-Watch50

In your opinion what was Shannon's saint moment and what was her sinner moment?

For reference, this would be Shannon at her absolute best and her absolute worst.

My Picks:

Saint Shannon: Officially and temporarily filling in for Dawn while she was in California for six months (Book 68 Jessi and the Bad Baby-sitter until Super Special #12 Here Come the Bridesmaids!)

Sinner Shannon: All of the mean pranks and rude behavior that she exhibited towards Kristy (Book #11 Kristy and the Snobs)

In your opinion what was Logan's saint moment and what was his sinner moment?

For reference, this would be Logan at his absolute best and his absolute worst.

My Picks:

Saint Logan: Told the truth about the Badd Boyz stealing from the music store and from others (Reader's Request #2 Logan Bruno, Boy Baby-Sitter)

Sinner Logan: Losing his temper and getting short with Mary Anne over his poor baseball performance (#25 Mary Anne and the Search For Tigger)

9-1-1 will be airing on two networks today, 8-15-2026.

On ABC, they will be re-airing 9x01-9x03 from 8 PM E/S to 11 PM E/S.

And on USA, they will be airing 6x13-7x05 from 6:30 AM E/S to 5:30 PM E/S.

In your opinion what was Abby's saint moment and what was her sinner moment?

For reference, this would be Abby at her absolute best and her absolute worst.

My Picks:

Saint Abby: Keeping her grandmother's potential cancer diagnosis a secret as to not ruin her grandparents' costume party (#121 Abby in Wonderland)

Sinner Abby: Being an all-around bad sport (#110 Abby the Bad Sport)

In your opinion what was Jessi's saint moment and what was her sinner moment?

For reference, this would be Jessi at her absolute best and her absolute worst.

My Picks:

Saint Jessi: Making the wish for Danielle to go to Disneyland (#48 Jessi's Wish)

Sinner Jessi: Fighting with Mallory over Mallory going to boarding school (#125 Mary Anne in the Middle)

In your opinion what was Mallory's saint moment and what was her sinner moment?

For reference, this would be Mallory at her absolute best and her absolute worst.

My Picks:

Saint Mallory: Helps Marilyn and Carolyn Arnold tell their mother that they want to be treated as two separate people instead of identical twins (#21 Mallory and the Trouble with Twins)

Sinner Mallory: Got angry at Henrietta Hayes for not basing her books on her actual life and wrote a play that insults her brothers and sisters (#80 Mallory Pike, #1 Fan)

In your opinion what was Dawn's saint moment and what was her sinner moment?

For reference, this would be Dawn at her absolute best and her absolute worst.

My Picks:

Saint Dawn: Organizing the fundraiser and prize sleepover to help the Zuni tribal school in New Mexico after the fire burnt their school down (#44 Dawn and the Big Sleepover)

Sinner Dawn: Stealing her dad's credit card to fly back to Stoneybrook after his engagement to Carol (#72 Dawn and the We ❤️Kids Club)

In your opinion what was Mary Anne's saint moment and what was her sinner moment?

For reference, this would be Mary Anne at her absolute best and her absolute worst.

My picks:

Saint Mary Anne: When Mary Anne comes up with the idea for the memorial bench for Amelia (#93 Mary Anne and the Memory Garden)

Sinner Mary Anne: Getting mad and passive-aggressive at Dawn for not taking a message from Logan (Super Special #4 Baby-Sitters' Island Adventure)

In your opinion what was Stacey's saint moment and what was her sinner moment?

For reference, this would be Stacey at her absolute best and her absolute worst.

My picks were:

Saint Stacey: Befriending Mark Kubacki, a child who will be having a risky open heart surgery (Super Special #1 Baby-Sitters on Board!)

Sinner Stacey: Thinking that she is so much grown up than the other members of the BSC while also blowing off jobs to hang out with the popular clique (#83 Stacey vs. the BSC)

In your opinion what was Claudia's saint moment and what was her sinner moment?

For reference, this would be Claudia at her absolute best and her absolute worst.

My picks were:

Saint Claudia: Saving the Nicholls kids and their mom from the abusive father. (#117 Claudia and the Terrible Truth)

Sinner Claudia: Her behavior in the months-long feud with Stacey over a guy (Friends Forever #2 Stacey vs. Claudia through Friends Forever #7 Claudia Gets Her Guy)

In your opinion what was Kristy's Saint moment and what was her sinner moment?

For reference, this would be Kristy at her absolute best and her absolute worst.

My Picks were:

Saint Kristy: Organizing the Krushers for the kids who were too young for actual Little League. (#20: Kristy and the Walking Disaster)

Sinner Kristy: Her entire behavior with Cary when they did the Teacher for a Week program. (#122: Kristy in Charge)

I was re-watching season 9, getting ready for the new season, and I just didn't like Maddie's promotion plot. Her big moment of the season was getting promoted to Dispatch Manager after Sue's stroke, and I get wanting to give a character an upward trajectory, something to work towards to move towards new plots and heights, so the character doesn't peak and fall.

However, Maddie does not seem like she would have the time or energy to be running Dispatch and raising two small children, while her husband works anywhere from 12-48 hours at a time given that the show often switches up how long the 118's shifts are to fit the story.

Also, for as much as I love the show, they really should have thought about the optics of what it looks like taking a job promotion away from the more qualified queer character for a second time in two seasons, to give it to a straight character, who has less reason to want the job.

And the reason they gave for not giving the job to Josh was flimsy as hell, because Maddie knows how to delegate and ask for help. Josh has literally done Sue's job before and handled it. We've seen that Josh know this job inside and out better than Maddie does, and he has been doing twelve years longer than Maddie. It would be like promoting Ravi over Chimney.

Did anyone else seem put off by Maddie being promoted over Josh?

I think the reason that we all love the show, outside of the outlandish emergencies and plots, are the multi-faceted characters, who drive these stories and fuel our fandom. So with this opinion game, we'll be exploring the characters and see if there is some form of consensus among the fans in a general sense. Now, these choices can be one-off decisions or something that impacted the show as a whole.

Saint: What one act or decision would classify Bobby as a saint?

Sinner: What one act or decision would classify Bobby as a sinner?

Remember agreements and disagreements are welcome. This is to open discussion up about the characters as a whole, but please be kind.

And to get this game started, here are my answers:

Saint Bobby: He gave his life to save Chimney and his crew.

Sinner Bobby: He knowingly lied to Buck and purposefully stalled his returning to work, even though the others had returned, often with more severe injuries or states of mind.

I've been playing this game on the BuckTommy sub, and it's basically asking the commenters what their favorite and least favorites of a specific season are. Here are their answers. Do you agree? Disagree? And what would you change?

1. Best Storyline: Harry becoming a firefighter and Chimney finding his footing as captain.

2. Worst Storyline: Buck's sped-up opioid addiction and Hen's medical diagnosis.

3. Best Episodes: Handle With Care, Pick Your Poison, and Family History

4. Worst Episodes: War and Pick Your Poison.

An unusual overlap in choices over a long season.

5. Best Character Arcs: Harry and Chimney for the above reasons

6. Worst Character Arcs: Hen for all the bad decisions she made during her medical issues, May for barely having a plot, and Eddie for having his plots always secondary to everything else going on, when they should be front and center.

I've been playing this game on the BuckTommy sub, and it's basically asking the commenters what their favorite and least favorites of a specific season are. Here are their answers. Do you agree? Disagree? And what would you change?

1. Best Storyline: Eddie moving to Texas and working things out with Christopher and Bobby's reconciliation with his mother and brother and the events leading up to his death and funeral

2. Worst Storyline: Brad and Hotshots, Athena landing a plane, and Maddie's kidnapping

3. Best Episodes: Disconnected, Holy Mother of God, Lab Rats, and Masks

4. Worst Episodes: Invisible, Wannabes, Confessions

5. Best Character Arc: Bobby and everything he did this season including his relationship with Athena, taking back the 118, reconciling with his mother and brother, and all of the stuff leading up to his death, and Chimney for how he dealt with Bobby saving him and stepping up in the finale.

6. Worst Character Arc: Hen for her disjointed plots this season which kept her firmly in the middle of the road, Eddie for how all over the map his arc this season was and for not actually talking about the root cause of his and Christopher's issues, Buck and Tommy for a breakup that made no sense and seemed to come out of nowhere, and Buck's behavior during Eddie's move.

I've been playing this game on the BuckTommy sub, and it's basically asking the commenters what their favorite and least favorites of a specific season are. Here are their answers. Do you agree? Disagree? And what would you change?

1. Best Storyline: Buck's bisexuality, coming out, and the beginning of his relationship with Tommy, Chimney and Maddie's wedding, and Chimney dealing with his past, including Kevin, the Lees, and Doug.

2. Worst Storyline: The cruise ship disaster for being an episode too long during a shortened season and the whole Eddie-Kim disaster.

3. Best Episode: There Goes the Groom, You Don't Know Me; Buck, Bothered, and Bewildered;, Step Nine

4. Worst Episode: Ghost of a Chance, All Fall Down, and Rock the Boat

5. Best Character Arcs: Bobby's arc dealing with Amir, his heart attack, and the cartel, and Buck coming out and the start of his relationship with Tommy.

6. Worst Character Arcs: The Eddie-Kim arc, Athena and Harry's return storyline, and the Chimney-Maddie wedding for being less about them than it should have been in hindsight.

I've been playing this game on the BuckTommy sub, and it's basically asking the commenters what their favorite and least favorites of a specific season are. Here are their answers. Do you agree? Disagree? And what would you change?

1. Best Storyline Season 6: The lightning strike and Chimney and Maddie's engagement

2. Worst Storyline: Bobby, Wendall, and the rehab center and Denny and his bio-dad

3. Best Episodes: The Devil You Know and In Another Life

4. Worst Episodes: What's Your Fantasy?, Recovery, and Cursed

5. Best Character Arcs: Buck and his continued growth as a character, Athena dealing with her parents' aging and solving Tanya's murder, and Chimney and Maddie as a couple leading up to their engagement.

6. Worst Character Arcs: Hen for the waste of her three seasons of medical school and Bobby for the rehab center plot.

I've been playing this game on the BuckTommy sub, and it's basically asking the commenters what their favorite and least favorites of a specific season are. Here are their answers. Do you agree? Disagree? And what would you change?

1. Best Storyline Season 5: Eddie leaving the 118 for Dispatch due to Chris's trauma, May's continued growth, Eddie's PTSD, and Jonah being a paramedic/serial killer with a hero fetish.

2. Worst Storyline: Buck and Taylor's relationship leading to Buck cheating on her and asking her to move in, only to break up by the end of the season, Hen's bad advice to Buck about not telling Taylor the truth about kissing Lucy, and Claudette's weird beef with May.

3. Best Episode: Boston, Defend in Place, May Day, and Hero Complex

4. Worst Episode: Past is Prologue, Desperate Measures, Ghost Stories, and Home and Away

5. Best Character Arc: Eddie and his entire arc for the season, May with her continuing growth, and Chimney and Maddie's shared arc.

6. Worst Character Arc: Buck for his messy relationship with Taylor and Hen for having to deal with more Eva stuff, telling Buck to not tell Taylor the truth about kissing Lucy, and for treating Chimney's replacements awfully, even though she ended up being right about Jonah.

I've been playing this game on the BuckTommy sub, and it's basically asking the commenters what their favorite and least favorites of a specific season are. Here are their answers. Do you agree? Disagree? And what would you change?

1. Best Storyline Season 4: Maddie's pregnancy and all of the ensuing drama with her parents, Buck and the Daniel stuff, Jee's birth, Chimney's fear during the pandemic, and Hen and Karen fostering Nia.

A bit controversial, but some liked the issues between Bobby and Athena near the end of the season, and others disliked them.

2. Worst storyline: Eddie and the Munchausen kid, Eddie and Ana's relationship for being dull, and Hen's medical school stuff for going nowhere in the end.

3. Best episodes: There Goes the Neighborhood, Buck Begins, Jinxed, Blindsided, and Survivors.

Treasure Hunt was controversial because some listed it as their favorite and others listed it as their least favorite.

4. Worst episodes: Breaking Point and 9-1-1, What's Your Grievance?

5. Best character arcs: May for coming into her own at dispatch and Buck for going to therapy and learning about himself and his past, and finally confronting his parents.

6. Worst character arcs: Eddie and Ana for having no chemistry, Buck and Taylor's good friendship turning romantic, and using Albert for plot when you could have used Ravi in his introduction season.

I've been playing this game on the BuckTommy sub, and it's basically asking the commenters what their favorite and least favorites of a specific season are. Here are their answers. Do you agree? Disagree? And what would you change?

1. Best storyline season 3: Buck and Christopher versus the tsunami, Chimney and Karen getting drunk together, and the introduction of Albert Han.

2. Worst storyline: Eddie's rage leading to the fight club and nearly killing a guy and Buck versus Bobby.

3. Best Episodes: Athena Begins, Sink or Swim, and The One That Got Away

4. Worst Episodes: Rage, Fools, and Seize the Day

5. Best character arcs: Buck dealing with his loneliness and being left behind and his friendship with Eddie post-lawsuit, Hen choosing to go to medical school and her hit-and-run with the violin prodigy, and Athena and Bobby settling into married life.

6. Worst character arcs: Michael and his tumor, Maddie trying to help the abuse victim, and Eddie's rage and the fight club, while not really dealing with the underlying issues of his grief.

So, do you agree? Disagree? What would you change?