u/Accomplished_Lynx480

Image 1 — Confused by "all" in syllogisms
Image 2 — Confused by "all" in syllogisms
▲ 1 r/UCAT

Confused by "all" in syllogisms

The stimulus states that all of the musicians at a concert are able to sing.

But what if there was only 1 person at the concert? If there was only one musician at there concert, it is possible that they are the only musician who is able to sing whilst enjoying classical music.

Does "all" have to refer to a population greater than 1?

u/Accomplished_Lynx480 — 9 days ago