Are we overestimating how much targeting actually matters?
It feels like a lot of the industry is still obsessed with getting the "right audience", but in my experience, there are a lot of campaigns where:
- mediocre targeting + strong creative → performs well
- very precise targeting + weak creative → underperforms
With signal loss, privacy changes, and more reliance on modeled audiences, targeting is getting fuzzier anyway. It makes me wonder if we are over optimizing for who sees the ad, and under investing in what they actually see.
What do you think, is targeting still the main lever, or is creative doing more of the heavy lifting now?