u/Aethelwulf_OCothra

Prepping for multiple registrations

Hi everyone! I'm an American prepping to register my arms with multiple private registries. I’ve been told that different heraldic registries — including highly respected ones — may apply their own house styles or even idiosyncratic preferences when writing (blazoning) arms. For example, I was told that the old NEHGS/American Ancestors register has long used its own distinctive blazoning style, while other private registries often mirror the traditions of their home heraldic authorities (English, Scottish, Canadian, etc.).

That surprised me a bit, because I had assumed the blazon was almost “sacrosanct” — that once established, it would remain essentially identical everywhere, regardless of registry.

So now I’m wondering:

If someone registers the same arms with multiple registries, is it normal for the blazon wording to differ between them?

Are these usually just stylistic/grammatical differences, or can they become substantively different?

Is the blazon best understood somewhat like heraldic artwork — interpreted through the traditions and preferences of the particular herald or registry?

Or is there generally considered to be one “canonical” wording that ought to stay fixed everywhere?

How much variation is considered acceptable before people would say the arms themselves have actually changed?

Please help me to understand this, thanks everyone! I’d be especially interested in hearing from people who have registered arms in more than one place.

reddit.com
u/Aethelwulf_OCothra — 4 days ago

Armorials?

Hi everyone,

I'm an American preparing for registration on multiple armorials ahead of receiving my first professional emblazonment from an artist. I want to register with as many as possible, with the goal being documenting the existence of my arms for long-term posterity. I figure if three out of four go kaput in the next hundred years, at least some will survive, for example.

I've come up with this list of armorials, mostly in the US but with one in Ireland due to family history and the fact that the official register there is not currently functioning:

Committee on Heraldry (NEHGS)

American Heraldry Society Roll of Arms

American College of Heraldry

U.S. Heraldic Registry

International Society of Commoners Heraldry (ISCH)

Heraldry Ireland / Araltas Éireann

Can anyone suggest any others I may have missed that would be worthwhile? Thanks!

reddit.com
u/Aethelwulf_OCothra — 10 days ago