No doubt that these charms aren't good everywhere; one of these is better at something but worse at something else. But I've always had trouble choosing when to choose either of these. One of the main problems that I find with Divine Relic is the random weapons whenever you stop shooting, use an EX attack, use a super, or even dash, but heart ring with wheatstone makes it a bit better, Chalice starts with an extra hp, and has double jump, the roll, and doesn't randomize weapons everytime i stop shooting, but oh god, no way to get back even a single HP