
The Second Strike in the Andamans
Following the suicide of Indu Bhushan Roy, the mental breakdown and torture of Ullaskar Dutt, and the worsening treatment inside the Cellular Jail, political prisoners in the Andamans organised another strike.
In the previous part, we already covered the first strike in the prison, after which the punishment of the kolu was restricted to rare instances. This time, however, the prisoners demanded recognition as Political Prisoners, better treatment, lighter labour, and permission to work outside the prison like ordinary convicts.
> As soon as I had completed my one year in the Silver Jail, I began sending petition after petition to be sent out for work. During one year and a half, I had the misfortune to be caught by Mr. Barrie and appear twice before the Magistrate on charges framed by him against me.
> First, on having written an anonymous letter to a person outside the prison for some news and press-cuttings from him. Unfortunately, the man to whom I had entrusted the letter happened to be Mr. Barrie’s spy upon my movements, and the letter went straight to him…I was punished for it by one month’s solitary confinement.
> The next occasion for coming into Mr. Barrie’s clutches was the first strike. I had discussed in a letter how the strike was to be organised and carried on, and I was about to circulate it among the political prisoners.
> On a sudden my room was searched. The Officers had just stepped in when I threw the letter away. Somebody got hold of it and handed it over to the authorities.
> It was written in Modi script and the Officers could not ascertain who was its writer. Mr. Barrie got it read by one of his confidents. But the political prisoner dared not depose before me, when the case was on, that it was written by me. For he feared his other friends in the prison.
> Whereupon Mr. Barrie got his Bengali clerk to declare that the letter was written in Bengali, and to read it out before the Superintendent. But a friend on our side gave evidence to prove that the letter was not written in Bengali. “Damn me,” said he, “if a single Bengali alphabet appears in that letter.”
> The Superintendent was non-plussed, but Mr. Barrie held his own, and shouted: “Oh, Sir, these political prisoners have conspired not to give true evidence.”
> At last the clerk’s word was accepted as truth and I was sentenced to be manacled for a week.
This incident is also corroborated by Savarkar’s Jail History Ticket, which records that he was punished on 19 September 1912 for possessing a letter instructing other prisoners on the organisation of the strike.
Primary Reference: Jail History Ticket of V.D. Savarkar (1911–1921), Government of India, Home Department (Special), 60(D)-F/1921, Maharashtra State Archives, Mumbai.
Secondary Reference: Vikram Sampath, Savarkar: Echoes from a Forgotten Past, p. 360.
> Excepting these two cases against me, the rest of my period was completed without any flaw. As such, I kept on sending petitions for outdoor work, as it was my due after the lapse of one year and a half in that prison. For other prisoners who had been sent out before me had not only cases against them, but had also gone on strike. My brother had already put in two and a half years.
> Sometimes I got an answer as follows: “You are not a political prisoner; you are classed as an ordinary prisoner.”
> And I used to reply, “Ordinary prisoners include thieves, robbers, and dacoits. They also have among them some who have broken open prisons, escaped from them, are hardened criminals, and have been sentenced several times. But they are also detailed for outdoor work and have become petty officers and jamadars in this prison. If I am an ordinary prisoner, then I must get the same concessions as they. I should have been let out long ago. You should have appointed me as a petty officer or a jamadar. For I have not against me any charges of breach of discipline in this prison.”
> At long last, the Chief Commissioner wrote categorically that I was not to be sent out for any work outside the prison walls. The reason he had given for this final decision was that, though my conduct in that prison was exemplary, I had a very dangerous past behind me.
> If the past conduct was the criterion of decision, where was the point in the remark that my present conduct was unexceptionable?
> The sum and substance of it all was that I may behave well or ill, I was always to be treated as a prisoner. There was no getting out of that position, even for a slight concession.
> While I was being dealt with in this manner inside the prison, the political prisoners who were sent for work outside the prison were being treated more harshly than before.
> All of us had begun to think that it was part of our duty to make an organised move to retaliate on behalf of Indu Bhushan, the account of whose tragic end I have given in the previous pages. They had misrepresented him, and they had sought to prove that he had done himself to death in a fit of insanity. We felt that we must do something to set things right in this affair.
> And we decided, after considerable discussion and deliberation, that strike was the only weapon that could bring the authorities to their senses.
> We further felt that we must be recognised as political prisoners not only for purposes of maltreatment, but also for purposes of due concessions; that whether we were kept inside the prison or sent out on the settlement, we must be given comparatively light work to do, some writing work inside according to our ability, or some light work outside according to our status. Nothing should be forced upon us simply to undermine our health, as was being purposely done then.
> Political prisoners, other than those who had been transported here on life sentence, should be treated like ordinary prisoners, and so on and so forth. We put down these demands in serial order, and we selected two of us as our representatives to submit the petition personally to the authorities.
> In the petition, I had pointed out that prisoners on transportation for life did not get even the ordinary facilities of other prisoners, like sending and receiving letters, or occasional meetings with relatives and friends, or facilities to read and write, or to be taken up as petty officers. We were not recognised as ordinary prisoners entitled to these concessions, and we got no facilities as prisoners belonging to a special class.
> If we claimed any rights as political prisoners, we were put off with the excuse that ordinary prisoners would resent the partiality shown to us, and the prison officers would not be a party to such a decision.
> To sum up, we were subjected, as political prisoners, to all the disabilities of prison life in India and the Andamans, without the compensating facilities afforded to ordinary prisoners in all the jails of India, as well as in the Cellular Jail of the Andamans.
> I ended the petition with a solemn warning that no longer shall we tolerate such treatment of political prisoners in the jail presided over by Mr. Barrie.
> “No relief, no concession, then no work” —that was our final resolution on the matter.
> And, in the carrying out of this solemn covenant, we were prepared for the worst.
> Our petition, like all other petitions before it, went for nothing; and strike was the weapon we decided to employ. One by one, the political prisoners outside began to repair to their cells in the Silver Jail. The prisoners inside stopped all work on the fixed day, and thus the strike began.
It is also worth noting that Ladha Ram Kapur, former editor of Swaraj, was among the first prisoners to initiate the strike. His photograph is attached with the post.
> This was the second strike during my period in the prison of the Andamans.
> My brother had joined the strike on its first day. Prisoners were handled severely for this species of non-cooperation. Batch after batch of civil resisters was hauled up before the Superintendent, and sentences were passed upon them of putting on handcuffs, or chains on the arms, or shackles on the feet, or solitary confinement in the cells.
> Every block of the Silver Jail, and every room in that block, witnessed the scene of prisoners hanging with their manacled hands tied to the top above. Some tried to squat on the ground with the chains on their hands and feet. Others offered stern resistance when shackles were being put on their feet. Others deliberately broke the rule of perfect silence and kept on talking loudly with one another. Others, again, refused to stand up when Barrie would come to see them.
> Most of them had stopped work. When Mr. Barrie came, the petty officers announced him as “Sircar”. Ordinary prisoners, off their guard, would stand up. But the political prisoners, to a man, firmly sat upon the ground; and it took three men to dislodge each one from his seat and put him on his feet.
> Mr. Barrie would not like the exhibition of enforced respect, and he could not continue this exhibition endlessly.
> The political prisoners were given no food as retaliation against their stopping work. Some of these were given very scanty food to eat, and others were put on conjee without salt from week-end to week-end.
> Some skirmishing also began between the guardians of law and these passive resisters. So there were obvious signs of impending disaster all about the prison.
> When the news came to my ears, I sent for Mr. Barrie and warned him to take care. I added:
> They are at present only civil resisters. They disobey the law and you punish them for disobedience. And I don't blame you for that. But if you are going to punish them in a manner to infringe your own regulations, then these infuriated young men will not fail to retaliate. They will return blow for blow.
> They realise that you will crush them. But they are like vipers. Even a worm turns; and they will not fail to sting you to the quick before you are able to scotch them.
> The responsibility of all this will rest on your petty officers who hammer them, and who set on each one of them three of your creatures to pinion them and beat them down. Your petty officers are cruel, they are bullies and cowards. They abuse and they beat. The Pathan and the Punjabi Mussalman—they are your agents in this nefarious business.
> But, be sure about it, abuse will meet with abuse and blow will meet with blow before long. Our political prisoners are up to that game if you would have it. The Pathan and the Mussulman petty officers will stand aghast when they get such abuses from them—the choicest abuses, the like of which they may never have heard before. And abuse invariably leads to blows.
> And I have already warned you of the consequences; so you had better muzzle your men.
> This warning was not without its effect on Mr. Barrie. He misrepresented me, all the same, to his superiors as the arch-instigator of the strike, and of violence that would come in its wake.
> I had not yet gone on strike myself. For I was expecting every day my annual letter from home. I had asked the political prisoners to wait till they had received their letters. Besides, my letter always contained fuller news of events in India, and that had afforded all of us ample matter for discussion later on. It used to be circulated throughout the prison for perusal by political prisoners.
> As the time was near for receiving the letter, I had decided to postpone going on strike till the receipt of that letter. As I have mentioned above, my brother had already stopped work and joined the strike.
> As the strike went on, Mr. Barrie began to meet with insult from every quarter, as he had never done before that time. All the prisoners seemed to view things differently. They behaved with perfect indifference. He tried his utmost to re-establish his influence over them by striking terror into their hearts. How hard put to it he was!
> Many things had happened in this prison to spoil its discipline and lower the prestige of its authorities. And the resistance of political prisoners made that discipline and prestige totter to their fall.
> All the weapons in the armoury of its officers had spent themselves. Only caning remained to be used with such frequency as the other weapons were used. The officers were at their wit’s end what to do with us. They threatened us with the cane, but none of us minded that threat.
> At last the Chief Commissioner asked the Superintendent, as also Mr. Barrie, to make overtures to us. He told us through them to return to work. He promised that he would give light work to us, and assured us that he would see that the political prisoners would be sent out for work like ordinary prisoners.
> And, lastly, he also promised that he would definitely take up our case with the higher authorities to determine our status as a class of political prisoners.
> So some among us resumed work; and, as soon as it was resumed, they were given lighter work to do, and they were also sent abroad. When we got the news, a change of opinion began that we should not now strain too much.
> I had always considered it desirable that my friends, the political prisoners, should have the freedom of going out for work in the settlement, for I was sure that it would help me in my propaganda, and would pave the way for my escape from the prison. So I advised them to call off the strike and go to work.
> If all of them were not treated equally in the matter of outdoor work, we were free to declare strike once again.
> Within a few days the prisoners resumed their normal life, and my brother was one of them. The officers kept their word and sent many political prisoners on light work outside the prison, such as watching the coconuts, sweeping the streets, and so on.
> If they had continued this policy, the strike would have ended at once. But they refused permission to the ring-leaders to work outside. My brother, Mr. Wamanrao Joshi, Hotilal, Nani Gopal, and two or three others were denied that right. Of course, I was out of the question.
> I had never given up my work even during the progress of the strike, though I did not escape the charge that I was their ring-leader.
Reference: My Transportation For Life
Get the PDF of the whole book from here: https://savarkar.org/en/pdfs/My-Transportation-for-Life-Veer-Savarkar.pdf