u/AlternativeOffer4341

Got approved for Amex Platinum Reserve today.

Now after applying, I started seeing a lot of negative reviews on Reddit 😅 so confused whether I should activate it or not.

My calculations:

  • Annual fee effectively: ~₹11.8K (after referral)
  • Getting 11K + 8K MR points
  • Also thinking of buying 10K MR points from Amex for ~₹4K

So total spend becomes around ₹15.8K–16K and I’ll have around 29K MR points.

Plan is mostly to transfer points to Marriott Bonvoy.

Other benefits I see:

  • Priority Pass with 2 lounge accesses per quarter
  • Accor Plus / Taj benefits

Question is:
Is it worth keeping for just 1 year, using all benefits + MR points, and then closing/downgrading later?

At this fee point, cards like HDFC Infinia/DCB/ Travel one or Axis Atlas seem to give much better value from what I’m reading here.

People who already use Platinum Reserve:

  • Is the first year worth it?
  • How much real value did you extract?
  • Any hidden/underrated benefits?
  • Did you renew after year 1 or cancel/downgrade?

Would love honest feedback before activating 😅

reddit.com
u/AlternativeOffer4341 — 5 days ago