This debate will never end, and I want to know all your points of view.
I completed the original game 3 times and the remastered version 2 times, a total of 5 playthroughs.
In 3 of them, I chose to save Chloe because I believe she didn’t deserve everything that was happening to her in life—never finding out what happened to her best friend, never seeing Max again after her father’s funeral, among other things. And basically, throughout the game you keep saving her, so it almost feels wrong not to save her in the end.
Then, the last two times I played, I chose the town. After reflecting a bit, I thought about how life is sometimes unfair—you can’t always get your way. I thought about the justice that Nathan and the teacher deserved for Rachel’s murder. I also thought about Dana’s baby that was about to be born, and Chloe’s mom, Joyce. Even though the town is full of corruption, those reasons made me choose it.
What did you choose, and why?