
I posted about my Slack task manager here 3 months ago. Here's what actually happened (including 4 months of Slack review rejections)
Hey IH,
I posted Qevo here about 3 months ago, the inbox-style task manager where tasks get pushed directly to people's queues instead of getting buried in Slack threads.
Figured I'd share an update because the main thing that happened wasn't growth, it was a masterclass in getting rejected by Slack.
The Slack Marketplace review process is brutal
When I posted, the Slack integration was "pending approval." What followed was 4 rounds of rejections over 3 months. Every round had 4-5 specific issues to fix, then a 3-4 week wait to find out you missed something else.
Things I had to fix across the rounds:
The bot was named "Queue" but the app was named "Qevo." Confusing users apparently. Simple fix, but you only find out after a full review cycle.
My landing page showed /qevo as a command that grabs the last channel message. Reviewers tested it, it failed. Turns out the bot needs to be a member of the channel first. (Was not a requirement in their earlier versions). Had to auto join public channels, add a proper error message for private ones, and update the landing page copy.
They rejected im:history and mpim:history as user token scopes, "too much access to workspace data." So DM support via bare `/qevo` had to be dropped entirely.
My app listed Spanish as a supported language. They asked for proof. The bot responses were actually translated (using the user_locale field Slack sends in the slash command payload) but I had to explain how.
A typo in the long description: "Start using GQevo today." Only caught in review round 3.
The whole process took longer than building the original integration.
Where things actually stand
The Slack app is now what I am hoping is about to be approved as per my last messaging with them. Slack app is now approved and live
Email to task is still the feature that gets the best reaction. People immediately get it. Slack is taking months to ship.
What I'd do differently
Don't list a feature as "coming soon" or "pending approval" in your launch post. Just launch when it's ready. The Slack integration being in-progress for 3 months after my original post made updates awkward.
Read the Slack app review guidelines obsessively before submitting. The checklist they publish covers maybe 30% of what they actually check.
Still free for individuals, $3/seat/month for teams: getqevo.com
Happy to answer questions about the Slack review process specifically. It's not well documented and I wish someone had written this post when I was going through it.
I've also seen a few other founders here going through the same Slack approval battle. Would be curious if anyone else has tips or horror stories, mine was apparently a rough one