Horse by Horse Analysis of the Preakness Stakes and more
I must really be a Horse Racing fanatic….I mean I must be. With the defections of Kentucky Derby winner Golden Tempo, the connections of the apparently mega talented Crude Velocity deciding to pass the race, Grade: 1 Arkansas Derby runner up Silent Tactic is out while still nursing a sore foot, the race itself not even being run at its home track (Pimlico) for the first time since 1909 (Laurel Park), and of the field of 14, there is only one Grade: 1 winner, one Grade: 3 winner and a maiden, the Preakness Stakes is almost anti-climactic.
Yet I was up until all hours of the night this past week, super excited, studying, looking, watching replays, trying to find the winner of the second jewel of the Triple Crown.
Just to give you an idea of how I attacked this race, I started with the change in venue. Comparing the two tracks I mentioned above, Pimlico is extremely narrow at just 70 feet wide, making the turns tighter. This configuration often favors speed horses (on or near the lead) as narrow turns provide less time for late runners to build the (late) speed needed to run down the early leaders.
The Preakness at Laurel will offer a distinct difference, starting with a 95 foot wide track, which will allow the late runners more time and room to gather steam for the stretch drive.
So, the age-old reputation of Pimlico favors speed horses, for this year, is irrelevant.
Lastly, the surfaces are vastly different as Pimilco’s surface is “faster” that Laurel’s.
Laurel Park
Race: 6 (1:28 PM EDT)
Sir Barton Stakes Sponsored by Connelly Family Foundation to Benefit The Thoroughbred Aftercare Alliance
1) Reagan’s Honor’s races in January and February had his connections thinking about the Kentucky Derby….until he absolutely bombed in the Bluegrass Stakes. He drops in class, cuts back in distance slightly and should handle this field in a race with the longest name in the history of mankind.
2) Final Story missed by a half in a quickly run 7F debut, then came back and pulverized maidens at Keeneland last time out….major player in this spot.
3) Falcon Jet is a $750,000 son of Justify who ran well for Bob Baffert on the West Coast, then came East to Laurel and beat maidens easily….Could better this rating.
Race: 10 (4:11 PM EDT)
Dinner Party Stakes
1) Cruise the Nile has won five of six, including being unbeaten in three turf starts. I love his last race (on the turf) as this gelding was forced four wide on the turn, but leveled out beautifully down the lane to get up for the win. Tack on him running the final quarter mile in a shade over a blistering :22 seconds and you should have a winner.
2) Once again, I’m going to try to beat the morning line favorite Dresden Row even though it might prove futile. He certainly looks imposing on paper having won two back and scoring a 103 Brisnet Figure. As if that wasn't enough, he got a pretty serious trainer upgrade (Pletcher) and won convincingly again in his last.
3) The oddsmaker is on the money (literally) in this race as Fort Washington, who clearly looks third best, is a tough old pro who usually fires his best shot.
Race: 11 (4:53 PM EDT)
Gallorette Stakes
1) Awesome Czech has won or has been “right there” in her last six races in a row dating back to last year…..tepid choice in a ridiculously difficult race to figure out.
2) Accent lost for the first time in her career in her last after having to check hard just inside of the half mile pole.
3) I’ll be trying to figure out why Mahra’s Love is opening at 15-1 long after this is published. This gray filly ran very well in England last year then came here and (after a prep race at Turfway), she came flying late to just miss on this turf course while getting a mile in a good 1:34.3 last time out. She looks primed for a big race and I will definitely have her on some of my tickets.
Race: 12 (5:52 PM EDT)
Jim McKay Turf Sprint
1) After a tough trip (bumped early, squeezed, then forced four wide on the turn) Had to Have Him rallied from tenth position early to finish a close up sixth in his first start in 187 days last time. This five year old figures to improve off of that effort. Last piece of advice is to watch the board 3, 4, 5 minutes before post for further clues.
2) If Had to Have Him is cold on the board right before post, then take a long look at Chasing Liberty who also had a rough trip in his last (bumped at the break, angled out while six wide on the turn), yet just missed winning and Irad is your reinsman.
3) Outlaw Kid took advantage of the poor trips by the top two to pull off an 11-1 upset in his last. However, that was his first win in 21 months.
Race: 13 (7:01 PM EDT)
Preakness Stakes
Analysis by Post Position order, selections below
PP#1- Taj Mahal is an unbeaten, $575,000 son of Nyquist who just keeps getting better, highlighted by his tour de force win in the Frederico Tesio Stakes, the perennial prep race for this, last time out. To back up that statement, note his Brisnets in his three starts (85, 97 and a field high 101). His only downfall would be drawing the #1 post. However, he is extremely tactical, which means he is adaptable to any pace scenario. Bottom line here is he is a serious contender.
PP#2- Ocelli put a good scare into me at 70-1 in the Kentucky Derby as, when he surged to the lead at the three-sixteenths pole, I said “oh my God, an effing maiden is going to win the Kentucky Derby”!! As soon as I said that Renegade and Golden Tempo ran by. We have to tip our caps to him as he held well late, finishing third, beaten by just one length all told. So, the question here is: does the clock strike midnight for this Cinderella horse? Or does he build off that heroic effort and win the Preakness? It’s your call from there but for me, I like others more and he needs to prove that race was no fluke.
PP#3- Crupper has won two of his last three including a $200,00 Stakes race at Oaklawn in his last. That said, this son of Candy Ride would have to improve dramatically to even threaten in this race. 30-1 on the morning line? Yep…that seems about right…..pass.
PP#4- Robusta is well named as he is a big, robust horse. He does have some speed, so he might be prominent early. However, in his last two starts (Kentucky and Santa Anita Derbys) he’s been beaten a total of 33 lengths……next.
PP#5- Talkin is a $600,000 son of Good Magic who was impressive breaking his maiden at first asking and followed that up with a good second to runaway Champagne Stakes winner Napoleon Solo (the #10 horse in this race). Although his Brisnets have climbed of late (78, 87 91), he hasn't done all that much since the Champagne in October……next.
PP#6- I suppose one can make a case for Chip Honcho as he does have speed, finished less than two lengths behind eventual Kentucky Derby winner Golden Tempo in January, and gave the early Kentucky Derby favorite Paladin all he could handle in February. However, I can not make a case for him as he has lost ground in the stretch in his last three races, his one start at this distance was not good and, by watching his stride/motion, he is giving me signals that he has distance limitations. ….pass.
PP#7- I thought the humorously named The Hell We Did ran very well in his last (second in the Lexington Stakes) as it was his first start at a distance of ground, at a major racetrack and versus graded stakes competition. Coming off a 13 length romp at 6F (in a smoking 1:08 flat), he stalked the pace, vied for command and understandably tired slightly late. I loved his determination and he kept trying and kept trying even after being passed by the winner. If he improves off that race/experience, and I suspect he might, he could run well here.
PP#8- Bull by the Horns did look good rallying from last to win his synthetic debut in his last. However, the last time he ran against upper echelon three year olds in the Fountain of Youth, he lost by 19 lengths at 88-1….next.
PP#9- Iron Honor is a good looking, $475,000 son of Nyquist who won the Grade: 3 Gotham Mile in NY in just his second lifetime start, signaling he clearly has talent. I like him, but I was a little disappointed with his effort in the Wood Memorial last time. Listen, I know he drew the 12 post in the Wood and got hung out to dry like laundry on a summer day (four and five wide the entire trip) and yes, he got bumped hard early (which seems to distract him) mid race. However, really good horses overcome such things and what's up with the falling Brisnets through his first three races too? (99, 95, 88) Is it possible that even though his breeding screams distance, two turns might not be in his wheelhouse? On the flip side, he gets a rider upgrade and trainer Chad Brown said he is “doing well,” and is “very live in this race.”
PP#10- As I mentioned before, Napoleon Solo ran one of the most impressive races I’ve seen in a while in the Champagne Stakes last October. The problem is he’s done very little in two races since. Yes, he still has good speed, but has weakened late both times and both of those races were shorter than this one. I’m going to toss him until he starts reverting back to his Champagne form.
PP#11- Corona D’Oro showed speed and tired in his last race, which was against weaker competition and at a shorter distance. So, like Napoleon Solo, he doesn’t make a lot of sense to play. If you are looking for a reason to play him, he has been working very well of late and the great Johnny V is your pilot.
PP#12- Like a lot of horses in the Kentucky Derby, Incredibolt had traffic issues and was bumped. That said, I thought he ran a tremendous race while rallying from 14th position early to get 6th, beaten by just four lengths. I like the fact that trainer Riley Mott called dear old dad Bill Mott for advice about running him back off of a two week turnaround, to which the older Mott said "absolutely.” Crazy advice coming from a man who won the Derby last year but skipped the Preakness. Bottom line here is, off his Derby performance and his Colonial Downs race/win prior, he looms as the one to beat.
PP#13- Great White, as a gray, 17+ hands tall and weighing 1,365lbs, is well named. However, names don’t win races and this guy just seems overmatched. In his only serious test, this big monster, showed brief speed yet quickly shifted into reverse in the Bluegrass Stakes, being beaten by a total of 22 lengths…..pass.
PP#14- After beating maidens by 6+ lengths and then first level optional claimer/allowance foes, Pretty Boy Miah is sharp right now. However, even at his peak, is he good enough to beat these? I doubt it…
Selections
1) Incredibolt
2) Taj Mahal
3) Iron Honor
Also consider:
The Hell We Did
Ocelli