
Thought I tanked the product review panel for this Senior PM role... then suddenly got the offer
I applied for a Product Manager position last month and went through the whole three-stage process. My initial stakeholder interviews and case study presentation went fine, until the live product design interview. I completely froze up and botched a standard product estimation problem I usually handle with ease. Once I walked off that call, I was convinced it was over.
I applied for a Product Manager position last month and went through the whole three-stage process. My initial stakeholder interviews and case study presentation went fine, until the live product design interview. I completely froze up and botched a standard product estimation problem I usually handle with ease. Once I walked off that call, I was convinced it was over.
I was right to expect an answer soon, so two days later I got a polite rejection email mentioning they were moving forward with another candidate. I knew I should let it go.
However, a week later, out of nowhere, I got a new email from the same company. Turns out the other candidate decided to pull out, and they wanted to see if I was still interested. I said yes.
I also just found out I have another CV version which was indeed very manual. I had a professional CV writing service to do the work on it, but I had forgotten about it because I didn't have high hopes for services like that. So my process was successful. When I was sending out the CV I had written myself, I ran into problems with CV Headlines, CV Designer, and CV Edit in general, and I thought my other cover letter had the same issues.
Now I'm struggling to reconcile this. It also had a team of editors, so that helped me finish my resume and feel more confident that it would work.
Now I'm nervous. I didn't "fail" as badly as I thought, or if the CV did most of the work before I even opened my mouth. Also makes me question how much interviews actually matter vs. first impression from your CV.
What do you think, did I really get the offer?