Help/advice researching family that would've lived in New York City in the mid-19th century.
Hey all,
I'm reaching out to this board because of this letter here, which is in my grandfather's grandfather's things. https://www.familysearch.org/en/tree/person/memories/L2FN-NDX (family search link)
The man in question, William Mulcahy, is an ancestor of mine who died in Halifax in 1869. He apparently came from a family outlined by this letter, that lived in New York. His parents, according to a marriage record, were named John and Catherine - but i have no idea if they ever made it across the pond from Ireland/Scotland.
The problem is, of course, that we don't really know how he spelled his name. It eventually became "McKay" in our lineage, but I don't know if this family, William McKay and his siblings, would have spelled it that way or something else. I've seen Mulcahy, McCahey, etc. in the records I do have.
The other problem is, I can't find the family referenced in this old letter anywhere in records from New York City. This letter is all i have to go on, and it's talking in the 1890's about a family in the 1860's, so I am sure there's a detail or two missing or misaligned here, which makes this even more challenging, on top of this incredibly common name. I've tried using ancestry's soundex and wildcard characters but haven't been able to turn up anything. Are there tricks/advice anyone can provide for me to researching a family with a common name in New York from this era?