Surcee
Author’s note: This is a slow burn piece of social horror with southern gothic undertones that I wrote a while back. It leans more on atmosphere and unease rather than on overt scares. I wrote this a while back and debated whether to post. If this doesn't belong here, I understand. A “surcee” is a small, unexpected gift.
-----
Emma was on her last trip to the truck, still not used to how this street felt smaller than she remembered. She’d tell people she was moving back now for work. That was easier. The house opposite hers leaned toward her. Its porch wrapped tight around itself. The magnolia tree beside it cast a shadow that reached into her yard. She had loved this part of town ever since she was a girl, playing hide-and-seek in this neighborhood until her mother stopped her. Even now, she could still map her old hiding place without thinking: through Ms. Anne’s camellias, behind the bent oak.
She caught herself staring across the street at three elderly women rocking on the porch, tea glasses in hand. The least they could do was offer help, Emma thought, snorting at the image of these old women in their Sunday best helping with boxes that she could barely manage. One of their rockers slowed to a stop as if the woman had put a name to a face. Their eyes tracked her.
Clink!
The sound carried farther than it should’ve; clumps of ice breaking in sweet tea glasses. Emma had to catch her breath as her arms weakened under the weight of the box. Sweat matted her blouse against her skin. Her heartbeat throbbed in her ears. Laughter burst from that porch across the street.
She shifted the box over to one hip to climb her porch stairs. She searched for her keys while navigating the thick air. The sea breeze she had become used to had spoiled her. As she opened the door, her keys fell from her hand. “Goddammit,” she bent to retrieve them and glanced up at the women across the street. All three leaned forward and set their cold glasses on coasters. She entered her new house and shut the door.
The only thing the house needed desperately was paint. She thought the realtor was joking when they first pulled into the driveway. It had been painted a tired green and was flaking badly. The trim had yellowed with time. But she had always loved craftsman homes, and a fresh coat of paint would make this house her own.
She settled on a dark color. Indigo felt right and would contrast well with a fresh white coat on the trim. She decided to paint the porch ceiling haint blue. It was a comforting color to her because her grandmother always said it was a color of protection.
The job was done quickly but professionally by a man she knew from high school, “Folks around here usually prefer softer colors,” he would say.
“Then I’m glad they aren’t living in it.”
The morning after the job was complete, Emma went out for errands. As she opened the door, a pie had been left at the base of the steps with a note:
^(Welcome Neighbor,)
^(I wanted to bring you this surcee. I am sorry I couldn’t make it all the way up your steps.)
^(Harriet)
She brought the pie inside. The crust was crimped with a professional look. The lattice work was clean and even. It didn’t show any signs of having bubbled over. Emma thought it was store-bought, but it was still warm. The smell of warm apple and cinnamon almost tempted her to take a piece now, but she made room for it in the refrigerator.
The main street, which had once felt massive to her as a child, had rearranged itself. The hardware store was gone. The dress shop had become a tax office. Boarded-up windows hid failed businesses. Nestled between empty storefronts, Russell Street Cafe had taken the place of a shoe repair store that no one ever used. In the cafe, as she waited for her latte, the display case caught her eye. Among the various pastries were pies in tins.
“Latte for Emma”
With tight crimp and lattice work.
“Emma?”
When she returned to her house, she had mail waiting. The mail was mostly junk. One letter was thick and was mailed with no return address. The letterhead shouted at her:
^(ROSEWOOD HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMITTEE)
^(Dear Ms. Harper,)
^(Welcome back to Magnolia Street. We were pleased to see your exterior updates and appreciate your selection of a seldom used but acceptable color for the residence.)
^(We noted the application of haint blue to the porch ceiling. We recognize the regional significance of haint blue and will allow it.)
^(For all future exterior alterations, including paint, fixtures, landscaping, or structural modifications, please remember that prior approval is required. The Committee is happy to provide a list of approved contractors and painters, should you need recommendations.)
^(We trust you will consult the Committee before undertaking any additional changes.)
^(Warm regards.)
No signature line, no number. She didn’t remember the realtor mentioning a historic district, so she called the city.
“Hello, this is Glenda. How can I help you?
“Hello, my name is Emma. I just moved into the Rosewood neighborhood. I received a letter from the Rosewood Historic Preservation Committee.”
“From who?”
“They’re telling me I need approval for paint, landscaping,” Emma scanned the letter for more information to give.
“This isn’t something we handle. Check with your HOA if you have one.”
After ending the call, she folded the letter and placed the thick paper back into its envelope. So much effort. For what? She decided to place it gently in the junk drawer before opening the fridge to grab a bottle of water. Russel Street Café was pressed into the rim of the tin. She stood there a moment, the cold air settling around her, then closed the door.
Emma had taken steps to form new friendships the best way she knew how, at church. Church in this town was the biggest door to new connections. She settled on one within walking distance of her house. The old women sat together in their pew much like they did on the porch. Harriet, Emma found, was the one who was always in the center. Emma would always leave earlier than the women to walk back after the service, and when she would round the turn to her house, there they would be.
On a particularly rainy Sunday, when she decided to drive, she was mortified to see the banner announcing that the potluck was today after the service. She sat in the back to slip out a few minutes early to grab a store-bought cake. When she entered the fellowship hall, she was met with a wall of smells, fried chicken, and every casserole under the sun.
Everyone had placed a card in front of their dish with their name and, optionally, a recipe. Her mother’s voice echoed in her head, “Never trust a potluck recipe. It’s never been made the way they say, and if it has, it’s probably no good.” Emma placed her cake down at the dessert table and wrote her name on a note card.
Clink!
So many homemade cakes and pies lined the table. All the hard work that had gone into them, and hers got her out of church early. She slid her cake in its plastic clamshell to the back of the table. She decided to get over the cake by fixing herself a plate of different casseroles. She made it a point to pass by Harriet’s table to properly introduce herself and thank her for her pie. All three were immaculately dressed in floral dresses. Emma forced a brightness she had never really felt.
“Ms. Harriet, I’m Emma, your new neighbor across the street. I realized I never properly thanked you for the pie.”
“That was nothing. Just a little surcee.”
“We like to welcome people properly.” One chimed in.
“Yes, ma’am! Thank you so much.”
Harriet continued, “This is Martha,” placing her hand on the shoulder of the one who had just spoken, “and this is Ada, you’ve maybe seen us around.”
“We are so happy you came home,” Ada added.
Emma maintained her forced smile and continued with Harriet, “I appreciate it. I’m sorry about the steps.”
“Oh, honey, those steps looked freshly done. Wouldn’t want to scuff anything up.”
“Well,” Emma paused, “it was a beautiful pie. Like the ones on Russell Street.”
Harriet’s eyebrows raised, “Mine tastes better though?”
“Why of course it does, Ms. Harriett.” Emma continued to smile, and Harriet’s shoulders became more relaxed.
Martha leaned back in her chair and changed the subject. “Indigo is a bold choice.”
“I think it might work on that house,” Ada said.
“Thank you, Ms. Ada. I didn’t know there would be an inspection.”
Ada’s smile thinned.
“I mean, I got a letter—"
Ada attempted to restore her smile, “Oh, you mean the Rosewood Letter. No, honey, we don’t inspect.”
Leaning forward, Harriet corrected, “We just keep an eye on things.”
“It’s what neighbors do,” Martha added
Emma hesitated, “I didn’t realize this was a protected district.”
Martha clicked her tongue in disapproval as Ada set down her fork and corrected, “It’s preserved.”
Harriet looked sternly at Emma and said kindly, “You remember how it used to be.”
“And it’s come a long way. I remember having to cross the tracks just to get over here.”
They shared flickering glances and shifted in their chairs for a moment.
Ada attempted to break the silence, “Yes. Well,”
Harriet’s smile returned, “We all feel so glad you chose to come back.”
“Most people don’t,” Martha added.
Harriet reached into her purse and pulled out a pen and notecard, "If you're still settling in, Mr. Carter keeps all our yards. I can pass your number along. He knows how things are done here."
“Thank you, I’ll keep that in mind.”
Emma excused herself to find a table. She was relieved the women hadn’t offered one of their empty chairs. Walking away with her rapidly cooling plate, Harriet whispered, “Store-bought cakes can be such a time saver.”
A table of strangers around her own age caught Emma’s eye. One woman at the table, Julia, took an interest in Emma and promptly invited her to the next Junior Service League meeting after hearing Emma discuss her involvement with fundraising at the Charleston chapter.
When Emma decided it was time for dessert, she made her way up to find only crumbs were left on most of the dessert trays. The cake was untouched. She wasn’t hungry anymore, so she cracked the plastic top back over the cake and left.
Leaves stained her yard while every other yard in the neighborhood stood pristine with trimmed hedges. Mr. Carter was expensive, and GreenGrass had never given her problems before, but they had cancelled again. She couldn’t have her yard looking like this for the Junior Service League luncheon. As she stepped out into her yard, she looked across the street at the women. For a moment, Emma wished another League member lived nearby to ask. They’re just old women, she told herself*.*
“Afternoon, Ms. Harriet.”
“Afternoon, dear.” Harriet lifted her glass for a slow sip.
“Ms. Ada, Ms. Martha, how’re y’all?”
“Good,” they said, almost in unison.
Emma shifted her weight, brushing a strand of hair from her face, “I was meaning to ask y’all something. Have you had any trouble with your yard people cancelling lately?”
Harriet’s glass paused just short of her lips, “No,” she said gently, “We haven’t.”
Ada put her cross stitch down in her lap, “We don’t use just anybody.”
Martha nodded, “Mr. Carter knows what we expect.”
Ada’s mouth curved slightly, “Some of these newer crews can’t quite keep up.”
Martha glanced towards Ada, “or they don’t understand how things are done here.”
Emma swallowed, “Well, I’ve been using GreenGrass for years and never had trouble.”
“Oh,” Harriet set her glass down softly.
“They disappoint people.” Ada gave a sympathetic hum.
Martha nodded, “And people don’t forget.”
The three leaned back in their chairs. Harriet smiled again, the same careful warmth, “Tell you what, I’ll call my Mr. Carter. He’ll come.”
Emma thanked her and stepped off the porch.
Clink!
The leaves shifted in a light breeze.
She grew up watching her grandparents rock away afternoons. She thought it was boring then. She bought a few chairs and a side table to fill in the porch space. They had gone unused; she couldn’t remember exactly when she had bought them. Even when Julia would come over to vent or gossip after work, they would always sit in the den.
Everything was in order, catering was secured through Harriet’s recommendation, and the lawn had been immaculate since switching to Mr. Carter. While watching him work, she wondered, Did he come here from the old neighborhood? He certainly isn’t from over here. She thought again of playing hide and seek as a girl and how the boy in the next town over getting struck and put an end to her mother letting her cross. Hopefully, the city put up crossing gates since she’d left.
Broom in hand, she set out to tidy up the porch. There was more than stray leaves and dust. Three evenly spaced arcs of moisture dotted the porch railing like someone had forgotten to use a coaster. Nothing was dripping from the ceiling. She spent the rest of her morning trying to remove the stains. They wouldn’t wipe out; the rings were stubborn and weren’t wet at all. It was like they’d been baked into the painted wood. After her arms could take no more, she finally gave in and used some spare paint from the shed to cover it up.
After her work was done, she decided to reward herself with a cup of coffee downtown. When she returned from her outing, the women were perched in their usual places. Chatting and sipping.
Clink!
As she climbed her porch stairs, there they were. Three evenly spaced rings stained her porch. That is it. She turned back, coffee in hand, and marched across the street.
“Emma, dear, is everything okay?”
“Have you seen anyone on my porch?”
“What do you mean?”
“Have you seen anyone up there? I have these three rings of moisture or…or something. Has anyone been ruining my house?”
“Help me understand,” Harriet requested.
Emma composed herself, “I spent all morning wiping down and painting over this mess. Have you come over?”
“Dearie, we sit here. Why would we come to your house?”
Emma let that go and softened her tone, “It’s a tough stain, and if you see it, you can give me some recommendations.”
Harriet smiled, “Well, dear, let me take a look.”
Emma offered her arm and guided Harriet down her own porch steps and across the street. They crossed Emma’s grass in silence until they reached Emma’s steps. At the top step, Harriet’s shoe hovered over the porch, then retreated.
“Oh,” she said, she’d only just noticed the distance between them, “You meant up there.”
“Yes. Look.”
Harriet leaned in as far as she could without moving her feet. The smile on her face didn’t change, but her eyes were cautious. “Well,” she murmured, “That is unfortunate.”
“Has someone been on my porch?”
Harriet’s gaze slid to the rings and away again, “Emma, honey, people don’t just… go onto other folks’ porches.”
“Then how do you think it happened?”
Harriet’s laugh was light, “I truly wouldn’t know.”
Emma’s voice tightened, “Could you recommend someone who can remove it?”
Her hand came to Emma’s arm, guiding her back down the steps like Emma was the one who needed assistance, “Come now, dear, you’re making yourself upset.”
Emma gently pulled her arm free. “I’m upset because someone is messing with my house.”
Harriet sighed, her voice went softer, “When you first move in, you watch for a while. Let folks show you how things go. It saves you,” she searched for kinder words, “trouble.”
“What trouble?”
Harriet’s eyes warmed, “The kind you don’t even notice is already there.”
Emma felt her stomach drop. “Are you threatening me?”
Harriet looked genuinely hurt, “Goodness me, no.” She patted Emma’s forearm reassuringly, patronizingly, “I’m trying to keep you from embarrassing yourself.” Emma stared as Harriet’s smile sharpened a bit, “You bought a house—,” but stopped there, letting the rest go. Harriet brightened as she continued walking toward Ada and Martha; the moment had passed.
“So? What has it?” Martha asked.
“It’s just a little mildew, ladies. Some paint will take care of it.”
They let the silence stretch until Harriet was back in her chair. Emma left the porch without waiting for dismissal. She didn’t bother with the stains on the railing.
On Saturday afternoon, Emma received a phone call. It was Julia. She hoped the call wouldn’t last too long; she loved her talks with Julia, but didn’t have time to spare.
“Hey Julia, are you coming over? I have the episode recorded so we can skip commercials.”
“No, I watched it with Leah already. Just calling, is it a good time?”
“Of course, I wanted to go over the final headcount for—”
“There’s been a small adjustment.” Julia interrupted, “We have decided that Ms. Dantzler’s home would save you the trouble, you understand.”
“The trouble?”
"Ms. Dantzler has hosted before, and everyone knows what to expect. She knows best how things are done. But I am still looking forward to your day.”
“When?”
The question hung in silence until Julia cut it down, “Let’s focus on Ms. Dantzler’s, and we will get back to you. Okay?”
“Okay.”
“Okay. Uh-huh. Bye-bye.”
Emma held her phone to her ear long after the call ended, expecting Julia to continue or for laughter to break out on the other end.
Emma dragged herself out of bed that Sunday to attend church. She liked the preacher; she needed one of his uplifting sermons today. It was a far cry from what she had grown up with, what had driven her from attendance years ago.
She liked to get to church early now and socialize with the younger families and receive updates on their weeks. Her favorite game to play was to look at the bulletin and guess lines the preacher would use for his sermon based on the verses chosen.
There were always two, one Old Testament and one New. This week’s rotation was Proverbs 16:5 and Matthew 23:15.
Emma flipped to Proverbs,
Everyone proud in heart is an abomination to the Lord; Though they join forces, none will go unpunished.
Maybe Matthew’s verse would be better:
Woe to you, teachers of the law and Pharisees, you hypocrites! You travel over land and sea to win a single convert, and when you have succeeded, you make them twice as much a child of hell as you are.
Emma felt she was back home.
Clink! Clink-clink! The youth handbell choir began the prelude.
They only made two mistakes this time. Good for them. I wish they’d practice smiling the whole time so they don’t give those away...Nice stole today...I wonder if everyone closes their eyes...Do they?...Of course Julia’s a no-show...What part do we say again? I’m never going to get used to this debts and debtors thing...Let’s see what you make of these verses. Okay. Proverbs. Abomination. Lovely...Matthew is sounding a little more like John today...Is that supposed to be? Is he looking down on me? He doesn’t even know; Ada probably told him…Julia? They want me to sit down...I’m not; I’m not above anybody. I’m just… I’m tired. Not doing this for fun...Grace? Grace from them. From Harriet. Jesus. Standing up isn’t - It’s not arrogance - It’s just standing. I’m here. I’m still here.
And when Emma rounded the corner to her home, the rockers were moving.
Emma sat on her porch, lemonade sweating in her hand. The lawn lay precise in Mr. Carter’s care. The new coasters ordered from the recommended catalog rested beside her glass.
Across the street, Martha, Harriet, and Ada rocked in their chairs.
Creak.
Down the block, a moving truck idled. A young couple stepped out into the heat. The woman shifted a box over her hip and scanned the street, hopeful, uncertain.
Emma lifted her hand to give a small proper wave, then raised her glass and took a slow sip. Faint rings still marked the railing where she’d tried to scrub them away.
Clink!
The sound came from across the street, like a throat being cleared. She still had the paint in the shed. It would only take ten minutes to make her home look perfect again.
But she didn’t move. She set the glass down on the bare wood.
Across the street, three women rocked in unison.