
America’s War on Black Families
The slave trade separated married couples, with slaveowners exercising absolute control over their human property by deciding whether to allow or even force slaves to marry each other. Married slaves had no legal status, so their marriages lasted only until one partner was sold. After the Civil War, Whites resented the equality of legalizing marriages for Blacks, which threatened White control of Black labor.
A New Deal program created in 1935 to combat poverty was Aid to Dependent Children, which helped women who didn’t have breadwinning husbands. Unlike White women, Black women were expected to work and were denied these welfare payments. Despite Whites’ devaluation of Blacks and their marriages, the Black marriage rate was higher than the rate for Whites from 1890 to 1960. But that changed in the 1960s. As Blacks moved north in the Great Migration and civil rights activists defeated discrimination in welfare policy, it became easier for poor Black women to get welfare. White backlash against the civil rights movement eroded support for antipoverty programs and characterized Black female recipients as “welfare queens.” Labor market discrimination reduced Black men’s earnings, leaving Black women dependent on welfare benefits and subject to humiliating enforcement of the “man in the house” rule, which denied benefits if a man was living in the home. Consequently, many Black men abandoned their families to prevent the mother from losing benefits.
After the US Supreme Court struck down state “man in the house” rules in 1968, the government’s assault on Black marriages continued with President Nixon’s War on Drugs and the era of mass incarceration. By 2010, 4,347 of every 100,000 Black men were in prison, a rate six times higher than the White incarceration rate. In 1981, President Reagan signed a new federal law which treated a live-in partner’s income as if he were a stepfather, resurrecting the “man in the house” rule. Today, Black men experience the highest rates of mortality, unemployment, and incarceration, decimating the supply of Black men earning family-supporting wages, and causing the Black marriage rate to plummet. In 1960, 61% of African Americans were married; by 2020 it fell to just 30%.
Recommended reading: The Color of Welfare: How Racism Undermined the War on Poverty by Jill Quadagno