Smoke Test or Smoke Screen ? You be the judge
Soon Athens City will be smoke testing the sewers in the East State street area recently effected by storm caused flooding that led to sewage backflow into residents basement.
The obvious correlation between the rainfall event and the sewage event implies that our storm sewers and our sewage system are not well separated. Please note that this fact has been known for decades. Our sewage treatment plant upgrade in the 80's was driven by the fact that raw sewage would flow into the river during rain events because a lot of rainwater would enter the sanitary sewer system.
You might think that various administrations over the decades have worked to ameliorate the problems caused by this failure to keep the systems separate. You would perhaps be wrong, a public records request on system upgrades over the past 4 decades would clear that up.
Some events that come to mind are when Broney's sued the city for sewage flowing into their basement. I think this was in the 90's but look it up, this information is paywalled perhaps on the messenger site, but AI models used by google seemed to have sucked up everything ever written so ask google.
Possible conclusion, homeowners at fault:
The city will be looking for houses with gutters that are tied into the sanitary sewer rather than the storm sewer. They might find some of that, and they are incentivized to find that because that would be the homeowners problem, and would exonerate the city. The city has become pretty talented when it comes to avoiding blame or taking responsibility. If you don't believe me, ask your neighbors. My sewer was backing up and it was clearly the cities side and it cost me a lot to do what the city could have done and should of done. Ask anyone who has reported drainage issues only to be told "Oh that is not sewage" or "That is not caused by a water leak" only to be proved that it was sewage, or it was a water leak.
Possible conclusion, city at fault:
When the city finally dug up the street and repaired the faulty junction between my 4 inch sewer line and the city's sewer line I got a good look at a small piece of our infrastructure. It was a joke, not well sealed, not well done, potentially a source of storm water infiltration.
I suspect that a lot of the city's underground infrastructure is not well isolated and does not do a good job of keeping sanitary and storm systems separate.
I also suspect that the cities storm system is not well maintained and that it is clogged or collapsed in multiple areas. When that water has no place to go it raises the water table and that high water can infiltrate the sanitary system. Will smoke testing show these issues? I doubt it, or if it does I doubt the city is going to take the blame.
I have reasons for my doubts about the city taking ownership including the following. Personal experience, neighbor discussion, and observed behavior. For example, when the city sent 3/4 million dollars to a scammer, did you hear anything like "The buck stops here", or "we messed up?" If the administration said these things, I missed them. Feel free to correct me with quotes and sources. When Richland Flooded, and E State Street flooded the first response was a cover your ass type of response like "once in a lifetime rainfall" not we can do better.
The bubbling spring on North Congress is another example. During rainfall events the center of North Congress would "bubble up" obviously the tunnel or drain under the street was not handling the flow. That water would come up under the street, or in your basement, or into the sanitary sewer, or somewhere else that is not a good place for stormwater. I should note that this may have been fixed by the recent work, or it may have been made worse by the tons of gravel that were allowed to flow into the storm sewers by sloppy contractor work. I will take a look at the next rainfall event.
My other reason to doubt the city here is that during a recent rainfall event I walked around and noticed a lot of storm sewers are not functioning. Some of them probably just need to be dug out and flushed, others suffer from the road bed sinking or not being graded properly so that the storm sewer is not at a low point and water merely diverts around it, or over the curb causing problems downhill.
So if the maintenance crew can not be bothered to even check for functioning storm sewers that are plainly visible, I would suspect that the less visible infrastructure is in even worse shape.
Pay Attention
I am by no means claiming to have all the answers here, or to even know everything. Life is filled with wonderful other things to do than to track everything that the city does or doesn't do. But, I do think that the current administration is not responding to our needs, or our will. There are countless examples. It would be nice if we elected our representatives and they acted with humility and courage on our behalf. If they did that, then we could ignore them and go on with our lives trusting them to be our agents and to do what is right with our money. But.. when that is not the case then we all have to pay attention to the players and make a judgement on how well they are serving us. In particular Patterson, Stone, Chiki deserve some focussed attention. A single party town that lacks competitive primaries has real risks of encouraging non-responsive administrations at best, or corruption at worse. Quite a few of our city/county officials have ended up in court, or in orange jumpsuits, so this is not idle speculation.
If you pay attention, watch a few council meetings, read a few articles and think we are doing great, that's cool. If you think we are facing financial challenges and our administration is doing the best that they can, that's cool. I suspect otherwise, but I respect any reasonably well informed decision.
One final note.. our tax increase passed by a few votes, perhaps based on a promise of weekend bus service. So let's get together and chat on a saturday bus ride through town... spoiler alert, there is no weekend bus service. Way to go Patterson, that lie got you some cash, the least you could do is spend something on infrastructure rather than vanity projects..
--
BWD