Coming to the realization most younger kids don’t actually understand jokes yet 😭
I’m becoming more and more convinced a majority of kids don’t actually understand jokes yet 😭
(well, at least a lot of the students in the K - 3 age range I teach!) idk if this is an obviously known fact to everyone else, but as someone with no kids of my own, I never had a reason to notice/think about this until I started teaching
The first time this realization dawned on me was in my first year of teaching. One day in my 2nd grade reading class, a student walked in carrying a joke book he was reading for fun. During break time, I asked him to pick a random page to read a few jokes out loud to the class, and they all got a grand ol giggle in before returning back to classwork.
Before the class session ended, I told em a classic "what did one ___ say to the other?" joke. You would've thought my classroom was the Apollo and I just performed the greatest comedy set of all time with the laughter I got 🤣😭 once the dust settled, some kids felt inspired and tried cracking their OWN jokes .... THIS was the exact moment it first hit me
"hey uh wait a sec, they all have NO idea how jokes work"
Every single kiddo who tried, even the one with the joke book, spewed out complete nonsense 😫 not some abstract, absurdist "nonsense" that's funny for some deeper conceptual reason, ohhhh no no no, literally just random (honestly mad-lib coded) sentences which ALL failed to make a lick of sense. Didn't matter to them tho!!!
They all laughed at each other's jokes like a pack of hyenas. I couldn't bring myself to rain on their parade and break their little hearts by telling em none of it made any sense.
THEN, last Halloween (with a completely different class of 1st graders btw), I showed them how Laffy Taffys have jokes on the back, and BOOM same situation repeats: they collectively lose it at the jokes, they try out their OWN jokes, all the joke attempts make ZERO sense, the crowd goes WILD anyway!! that's when I knew my "hypothesis" here wasn't a fluke LOL
Some of em are soooooo close to getting it too 🤏 like they understand there's some sort of structure/setup to a joke that needs to be followed and it's their job to fill in the blanks, BUT they just don't understand the concept of a punchline yet 🙂↔️ maybe next year lol
btw btw I'm NOT mentioning this to judge them or call them unfunny behind their backs, this is NOT a complaint! tbh, it's infinitely more endearing than anything + I wanted to share my observation ~
I'm not the comedy police writing up tickets for their lack of funny material LOL
Feels good to know I can be even MORE confident cracking jokes in class now because I as long as my delivery is good, they'll find anything I say hilarious 🙌
Any of y'all who teach in this age range noticed this as well? or does anyone have opposing testimonies LOL like maybe a student who was actually super clever/witty with their jokes??