u/Burgundymmm

This post contains content not supported on old Reddit. Click here to view the full post

Jack Frost won! Who will take Hero's spot? (Third party only)

Make a roster of characters who have never been playable in a Smash game! Let's try to make a nice, diverse, semi-realistic roster (major franchises represented well, retro reps, playstyle variations, and so on).

Highest voted eligible character gets added to the roster. Video game original characters only.

For Ultimate, characters must have debuted before 2018.

3rd party characters will only allowed in the place of the original games' 3rd party characters.

Characters that were costumes (Alph, Koopalings) are not eligible. Variations of existing characters (like Dr. Mario or Toon Link were) will be allowed at my discretion.

Ninten model by Averagejoey543 on deviantart

Wart model by smashifiedart on deviantart

Mach Rider model by Nibroc-rock on deviantart

If any of the other models I used were fan art let me know so I can credit!

Shovel Knight and Black Knight are our winners! Today is another echo fighter vote for Chrom's spot. Has to be first-party and from any veteran on this roster.

Make a roster of characters who have never been playable in a Smash game! Let's try to make a nice, diverse, semi-realistic roster (major franchises represented well, retro reps, playstyle variations, and so on).

Highest voted eligible character gets added to the roster. Video game original characters only.

For Ultimate, characters must have debuted before 2018.

3rd party characters will only allowed in the place of the original games' 3rd party characters.

For the spots of Echo Fighters based off veterans, an Echo of any veteran on our roster is valid. For characters who debuted with their Echo, these characters will be voted on together.

Characters that were costumes (Alph, Koopalings) are not eligible. Variations of existing characters (like Dr. Mario or Toon Link were) will be allowed at my discretion.

Ninten model by Averagejoey543 on deviantart

Wart model by smashifiedart on deviantart

Mach Rider model by Nibroc-rock on deviantart

If any of the other models I used were fan art let me know so I can credit!

Black Mage is our winner! For Corrin's spot, the rules will be a little different. Needs to be a first party character, but they should have debuted in either 2014 or 2015.

Make a roster of characters who have never been playable in a Smash game! Let's try to make a nice, diverse, semi-realistic roster (major franchises represented well, retro reps, playstyle variations, and so on).

Highest voted eligible character gets added to the roster. Video game original characters only.

Character must have debuted before the game's release year, so prior to 2014 for Smash 4.

3rd party characters will only allowed in the place of the original games' 3rd party characters.

For the spots of Echo Fighters based off veterans, an Echo of any veteran on our roster is valid. For characters who debuted with their Echo, these characters will be voted on together.

Characters that were costumes (Alph, Koopalings) are not eligible. Variations of existing characters (like Dr. Mario or Toon Link were) will be allowed at my discretion.

Doc Louis wins! Today is Greninja's spot!

Make a roster of characters who have never been playable in a Smash game! Let's try to make a nice, diverse, semi-realistic roster (major franchises represented well, retro reps, playstyle variations, and so on).

Highest voted eligible character gets added to the roster. Video game original characters only.

Character must have debuted before the game's release year, so prior to 2014 for Smash 4.

3rd party characters will only allowed in the place of the original games' 3rd party characters.

For the spots of Echo Fighters based off veterans, an Echo of any veteran on our roster is valid. For characters who debuted with their Echo, these characters will be voted on together.

Characters that were costumes (Alph, Koopalings) are not eligible. Variations of existing characters (like Dr. Mario or Toon Link were) will be allowed at my discretion.

Paper Mario & Partners wins! Today is Little Mac's spot!

Make a roster of characters who have never been playable in a Smash game! Let's try to make a nice, diverse, semi-realistic roster (major franchises represented well, retro reps, playstyle variations, and so on).

Highest voted eligible character gets added to the roster. Video game original characters only.

Character must have debuted before the game's release year, so prior to 2014 for Smash 4.

3rd party characters will only allowed in the place of the original games' 3rd party characters.

For the spots of Echo Fighters based off veterans, an Echo of any veteran on our roster is valid. For characters who debuted with their Echo, these characters will be voted on together.

Characters that were costumes (Alph, Koopalings) are not eligible. Variations of existing characters (like Dr. Mario or Toon Link were) will be allowed at my discretion.

Chibi-Robo won! Next, who takes Rosalina & Luma's spot? Bonus points if it's a puppet fighter like Rosalina but I won't be requiring it this time.

Make a roster of characters who have never been playable in a Smash game! Let's try to make a nice, diverse, semi-realistic roster (major franchises represented well, retro reps, playstyle variations, and so on).

Highest voted eligible character gets added to the roster. Video game original characters only.

Character must have debuted before the game's release year, so prior to 2014 for Smash 4.

3rd party characters will only allowed in the place of the original games' 3rd party characters.

For the spots of Echo Fighters based off veterans, an Echo of any veteran on our roster is valid. For characters who debuted with their Echo, these characters will be voted on together.

Characters that were costumes (Alph, Koopalings) are not eligible. Variations of existing characters (like Dr. Mario or Toon Link were) will be allowed at my discretion.

Phoenix Wright barely won today! Back to first party, who will take Wii Fit Trainer's spot?

Make a roster of characters who have never been playable in a Smash game! Let's try to make a nice, diverse, semi-realistic roster (major franchises represented well, retro reps, playstyle variations, and so on).

Highest voted eligible character gets added to the roster. Video game original characters only.

Character must have debuted before the game's release year, so prior to 2014 for Smash 4.

3rd party characters will only allowed in the place of the original games' 3rd party characters.

For the spots of Echo Fighters based off veterans, an Echo of any veteran on our roster is valid. For characters who debuted with their Echo, these characters will be voted on together.

Characters that were costumes (Alph, Koopalings) are not eligible. Variations of existing characters (like Dr. Mario or Toon Link were) will be allowed at my discretion.

Dang I was hoping for Nintendogs but Tom Nook is our winner! Next is Mega Man's spot. Reminder that any third party character who debuted before 2014 is eligible, does not have to be Capcom.

Make a roster of characters who have never been playable in a Smash game! Let's try to make a nice, diverse, semi-realistic roster (major franchises represented well, retro reps, playstyle variations, and so on).

Highest voted eligible character gets added to the roster. Video game original characters only.

Character must have debuted before the game's release year, so prior to 2014 for Smash 4.

3rd party characters will only allowed in the place of the original games' 3rd party characters.

For the spots of Echo Fighters based off veterans, an Echo of any veteran on our roster is valid. For characters who debuted with their Echo, these characters will be voted on together.

Characters that were costumes (Alph, Koopalings) are not eligible. Variations of existing characters (like Dr. Mario or Toon Link were) will be allowed at my discretion.

Well it was Krystal-clear from the start who was gonna win that last Brawl spot, but unfortunately Krystal is immediately cut for Smash 4! Sorry for the delay, but let's get started on the next game. Who takes Villager's spot as the first Smash 4 newcomer?

Make a roster of characters who have never been playable in a Smash game! Let's try to make a nice, diverse, semi-realistic roster (major franchises represented well, retro reps, playstyle variations, and so on).

Highest voted eligible character gets added to the roster. Video game original characters only.

Character must have debuted before the game's release year, so prior to 2014 for Smash 4.

3rd party characters will only be allowed in the place of the original games' 3rd party characters.

For the spots of Echo Fighters based off veterans, an Echo of any veteran on our roster is valid. For characters who debuted with their Echo, these characters will be voted on together.

Characters that were costumes (Alph, Koopalings) are not eligible. Variations of existing characters (like Dr. Mario or Toon Link were) will be allowed at my discretion.

Daroach won! Next, who takes Olimar's spot?

Make a roster of characters who have never been playable in a Smash game! Let's try to make a nice, diverse, semi-realistic roster (major franchises represented well, retro reps, playstyle variations, and so on).

Highest voted eligible character gets added to the roster. Video game original characters only.

Character must have debuted before the game's release year, so prior to 2008 for Brawl.

Characters that take the place of a fighter who gets cut from future installments will be cut from the same games.

Transformation characters will be limited to as many as are in the actual games.

3rd party characters will only allowed in the place of the original games' 3rd party characters.

For the spots of Echo Fighters based off veterans, an Echo of any veteran on our roster is valid. For characters who debuted with their Echo, these characters will be voted on together.

Characters that were costumes (Alph, Koopalings) are not eligible. Variations of existing characters (like Dr. Mario or Toon Link were) will be allowed at my discretion.

Lyn takes Ike's spot! Today is a special round, for the franchise's only 3-in-1 character. Reminder that they can be from any franchise. They will also be reduced to a single fighter temporarily for Smash 4, so bonus points if you mention which fighter is kept.

Notes for Brawl: Pokemon Trainer's spot will be a 3-in-1 character. Snake's and Sonic's spots will be our first 3rd party!

Make a roster of characters who have never been playable in a Smash game! Let's try to make a nice, diverse, semi-realistic roster (major franchises represented well, retro reps, playstyle variations, and so on).

Highest voted eligible character gets added to the roster. Video game original characters only.

Character must have debuted before the game's release year, so prior to 2008 for Brawl.

Characters that take the place of a fighter who gets cut from future installments will be cut from the same games (i.e. the fighter in Pichu's place will be cut until Ultimate).

Transformation characters will be limited to as many as are in the actual games (i.e. a 2 form character for Melee for Zelda/Sheik, and a 3 form character in Brawl for Pokemon Trainer).

3rd party characters will be limited to as many as are in the actual games (i.e. 2 for Brawl). None until then.

To make things easier, we'll ignore clones until we get to the characters labeled as echoes in Ultimate (which won't be until Lucina and Dark Pit in Sm4sh). So don't worry about Luigi or Jigglypuff's spots being clones.

Characters that were costumes (Alph, Koopalings) are not eligible. Variations of existing characters (like Dr. Mario or Toon Link were) will be allowed at my discretion.

Marx takes Meta Knight's spot as the first Brawl newcomer! Next, who takes Pit's spot? I do want to remind y'all that these don't have to be 1:1 with franchises. Like if y'all choose a Zelda character in a Pokemon's spot I'll move people around to keep franchises together.

Notes for Brawl: ZSS's spot has to be a transformation of a veteran. Pokemon Trainer's spot will be a 3-in-1 character. Snake's and Sonic's spots will be our first 3rd party!

Make a roster of characters who have never been playable in a Smash game! Let's try to make a nice, diverse, semi-realistic roster (major franchises represented well, retro reps, playstyle variations, and so on).

Highest voted eligible character gets added to the roster. Video game original characters only.

Character must have debuted before the game's release year, so prior to 2008 for Brawl.

Characters that take the place of a fighter who gets cut from future installments will be cut from the same games (i.e. the fighter in Pichu's place will be cut until Ultimate).

Transformation characters will be limited to as many as are in the actual games (i.e. a 2 form character for Melee for Zelda/Sheik, and a 3 form character in Brawl for Pokemon Trainer).

3rd party characters will be limited to as many as are in the actual games (i.e. 2 for Brawl). None until then.

To make things easier, we'll ignore clones until we get to the characters labeled as echoes in Ultimate (which won't be until Lucina and Dark Pit in Sm4sh). So don't worry about Luigi or Jigglypuff's spots being clones.

Characters that were costumes (Alph, Koopalings) are not eligible. Variations of existing characters (like Dr. Mario or Toon Link were) will be allowed at my discretion.

Sukapon finally wins, earning the last Melee spot! Unfortunately, Lip, Tingle, Togepi, Scizor, and Hector will be cut moving into Brawl. Now it is time for our first Brawl newcomer, who takes Meta Knight's spot?

Notes for Brawl: ZSS's spot has to be a transformation of a veteran. Pokemon Trainer's spot will be a 3-in-1 character. Snake's and Sonic's spots will be our first 3rd party!

Make a roster of characters who have never been playable in a Smash game! Let's try to make a nice, diverse, semi-realistic roster (major franchises represented well, retro reps, playstyle variations, and so on).

Highest voted eligible character gets added to the roster. Video game original characters only.

Character must have debuted before the game's release year, so prior to 2008 for Brawl.

Characters that take the place of a fighter who gets cut from future installments will be cut from the same games (i.e. the fighter in Pichu's place will be cut until Ultimate).

Transformation characters will be limited to as many as are in the actual games (i.e. a 2 form character for Melee for Zelda/Sheik, and a 3 form character in Brawl for Pokemon Trainer).

3rd party characters will be limited to as many as are in the actual games (i.e. 2 for Brawl). None until then.

To make things easier, we'll ignore clones until we get to the characters labeled as echoes in Ultimate (which won't be until Lucina and Dark Pit in Sm4sh). So don't worry about Luigi or Jigglypuff's spots being clones.

Characters that were costumes (Alph, Koopalings) are not eligible. Variations of existing characters (like Dr. Mario or Toon Link were) will be allowed at my discretion.

Wart takes Bowser's spot! Wow, SMB2 is very represented on this roster. Next is a special round for the Ice Climbers spot: submissions have to be a tag team character that works in the same way the Ice Climbers do. Submissions not following this rule will be ignored. (Note this fighter will be removed from the Smash 4 roster.)

Notes for Melee: Fighter #16 & #17 (Zelda/Shiek) has to be a transformation character. Fighter #25 (Roy) will be allowed to have debuted anytime in 2002. Wait until we get to these spots to submit fighters like them.

Make a roster of characters who have never been playable in a Smash game! Let's try to make a nice, diverse, semi-realistic roster (major franchises represented well, retro reps, playstyle variations, and so on).

Highest voted eligible character gets added to the roster. Video game original characters only.

Character must have debuted before the game's release year, so prior to 2001 for Melee. (Melee will get one Roy exception)

Characters that take the place of a fighter who gets cut from future installments will be cut from the same games (i.e. the fighter in Pichu's place will be cut until Ultimate).

Transformation characters will be limited to as many as are in the actual games (i.e. a 2 form character for Melee for Zelda/Sheik, and a 3 form character in Brawl for Pokemon Trainer).

3rd party characters will be limited to as many as are in the actual games (i.e. 2 for Brawl). None until then.

To make things easier, we'll ignore clones untils we get to the characters labeled as echoes in Ultimate (which won't be until Lucina and Dark Pit in Sm4sh). So don't worry about Luigi or Jigglypuff's spots being clones.

Characters that were costumes (Alph, Koopalings) are not eligible. Variations of existing characters (like Dr. Mario or Toon Link were) will be allowed at my discretion.

This post contains content not supported on old Reddit. Click here to view the full post

Waluigi, possibly the most iconic Smash reject of them all, wins the first newcomer spot on the Melee roster! Next, who is taking Bowser's spot? (I want to add since I mentioned it in the comments of the next post, I will move roster placements around to keep franchises together, if y'all choose Kraid for this spot or something, I will move him and keep the Mario characters together.)

Notes for Melee: Fighter #15 (Ice Climbers spot) is allowed to be a double character like them. Fighter #16 & #17 (Zelda/Shiek) has to be a transformation character. Fighter #25 (Roy) will be allowed to have debuted anytime in 2002. Wait until we get to these spots to submit fighters like them.

Make a roster of characters who have never been playable in a Smash game! Let's try to make a nice, diverse, semi-realistic roster (major franchises represented well, retro reps, playstyle variations, and so on).

Highest voted eligible character gets added to the roster. Video game original characters only.

Character must have debuted before the game's release year, so prior to 2001 for Melee. (Melee will get one Roy exception)

Characters that take the place of a fighter who gets cut from future installments will be cut from the same games (i.e. the fighter in Pichu's place will be cut until Ultimate).

Transformation characters will be limited to as many as are in the actual games (i.e. a 2 form character for Melee for Zelda/Sheik, and a 3 form character in Brawl for Pokemon Trainer).

3rd party characters will be limited to as many as are in the actual games (i.e. 2 for Brawl). None until then.

To make things easier, we'll ignore clones untils we get to the characters labeled as echoes in Ultimate (which won't be until Lucina and Dark Pit in Sm4sh). So don't worry about Luigi or Jigglypuff's spots being clones.

Characters that were costumes (Alph, Koopalings) are not eligible. Variations of existing characters (like Dr. Mario or Toon Link were) will be allowed at my discretion.

Eevee is the final character for the Rejects 64 roster! I don't know about you, but I think this roster would have sold millions. Now, onto Melee, who takes Peach's spot as the first Melee newcomer? (Remember, must have debuted prior to January 1, 2001)

Notes for Melee: Fighter #15 (Ice Climbers spot) is allowed to be a double character like them. Fighter #16 & #17 (Zelda/Shiek) has to be a transformation character. Fighter #25 (Roy) will be allowed to have debuted anytime in 2002. Wait until we get to these spots to submit fighters like them.

Make a roster of characters who have never been playable in a Smash game! Let's try to make a nice, diverse, semi-realistic roster (major franchises represented well, retro reps, playstyle variations, and so on).

Highest voted eligible character gets added to the roster. Video game original characters only.

Character must have debuted before the game's release year, so prior to 2001 for Melee. (Melee will get one Roy exception).

Transformation characters will be limited to as many as are in the actual games (i.e. a 2 form character for Melee for Zelda/Sheik, and a 3 form character in Brawl for Pokemon Trainer).

3rd party characters will be limited to as many as are in the actual games (i.e. 2 for Brawl). None until then.

To make things easier, we'll ignore clones untils we get to the characters labeled as echoes in Ultimate (which won't be until Lucina and Dark Pit in Sm4sh). So don't worry about Luigi or Jigglypuff's spots being clones.

Characters that were costumes (Alph, Koopalings) are not eligible. Variations of existing characters (like Dr. Mario or Toon Link were) will be allowed at my discretion.

Mach Rider takes Captain Falcon's spot! Who will take Jigglypuff's spot as the final reject on the roster?

Make a roster of characters who have never been playable in a Smash game! Let's try to make a nice, diverse, semi-realistic roster (major franchises represented well, retro reps, playstyle variations, and so on).

Highest voted eligible character gets added to the roster. Video game original characters only.

Character must have debuted before the game's release year, so prior to 1999 for Smash 64. (Melee will get one Roy exception).

Transformation characters will be limited to as many as are in the actual games (i.e. a 2 form character for Melee for Zelda/Sheik, and a 3 form character in Brawl for Pokemon Trainer).

3rd party characters will be limited to as many as are in the actual games (i.e. 2 for Brawl). None until then.

To make things easier, we'll ignore clones untils we get to the characters labeled as echoes in Ultimate (which won't be until Lucina and Dark Pit in Sm4sh). So don't worry about Luigi or Jigglypuff's spots being clones.

Characters that were costumes (Alph, Koopalings) are not eligible. Variations of existing characters (like Dr. Mario or Toon Link were) will be allowed at my discretion.

Ninten takes Ness's spot! Who is taking Captain Falcon's spot?

Make a roster of characters who have never been playable in a Smash game! Let's try to make a nice, diverse, semi-realistic roster (major franchises represented well, retro reps, playstyle variations, and so on).

Highest voted eligible character gets added to the roster. Video game original characters only.

Character must have debuted before the game's release year, so prior to 1999 for Smash 64. (Melee will get one Roy exception).

Transformation characters will be limited to as many as are in the actual games (i.e. a 2 form character for Melee for Zelda/Sheik, and a 3 form character in Brawl for Pokemon Trainer).

3rd party characters will be limited to as many as are in the actual games (i.e. 2 for Brawl). None until then.

To make things easier, we'll ignore clones untils we get to the characters labeled as echoes in Ultimate (which won't be until Lucina and Dark Pit in Sm4sh). So don't worry about Luigi or Jigglypuff's spots being clones.

Characters that were costumes (Alph, Koopalings) are not eligible. Variations of existing characters (like Dr. Mario or Toon Link were) will be allowed at my discretion.