u/CHOCOLATEDROP06

Consciousness and the brain

Consciousness and the brain are clearly separate but work perfectly together. Consciousness isn't the brain itself, and there's no mechanism for it. If you say the brain is consciousness, that means it's the source, not the mechanism. Consciousness is a subjective experience; you can't see it in a lab or experience mine, just like I can't experience yours. It's based on firsthand subjective experience, not just the brain. I see that a lot of people make up answers for the mechanism of consciousness. We don't know the mechanism of consciousness. That's why the whole concept of the problem of consciousness is proposed by actual people who study these things, like neuroscientists, not by people outside of these fields, because even they know there is such a thing as a problem with consciousness, in that we know this cannot be some physical thing. We cannot see consciousness itself. We can only see what correlates with consciousness, which would be the brain because consciousness and the brain work so perfectly together.

reddit.com
u/CHOCOLATEDROP06 — 1 day ago

Epistemology

It has been observed that a considerable number of scientists may not fully grasp the intricacies of epistemology or philosophy, notwithstanding philosophy's historical role in advancing civilizations. The scientific enterprise, encompassing its methodologies and the very construct of reality, is fundamentally supported by philosophical tenets. Absent a philosophical framework, the evolution of science, the scientific method, and the empirical validation of phenomena would face substantial impediments. Deliberations concerning the nature of reality inherently involve metaphysical considerations. The apparent detachment of many scientists from philosophy may arise from philosophy's inclination to investigate questions and pursue resolutions that transcend the immediate purview or current capacities of scientific inquiry. Consequently, there is a discouragement for individuals to pursue philosophy. This contributes to the contemporary diminished regard for philosophy compared to scientific disciplines or other fields of knowledge. This perception is often rooted in the belief that philosophy is an outmoded or superseded discipline, despite its enduring and significant influence on our understanding and articulation of reality.

reddit.com
u/CHOCOLATEDROP06 — 12 days ago

Even if religion never existed

Genocide, warfare, famine, and colonization would persist irrespective of religious beliefs, as these occurrences are intrinsically linked to fundamental aspects of human nature. Our advanced cognitive abilities and evolving comprehension position humanity as potentially one of the most formidable species on Earth. Unlike other animals, which may perceive humans solely as sustenance when driven by hunger, our elevated consciousness enables us to conceptualize and execute a broad spectrum of actions towards other living beings, encompassing both benevolent and malevolent intentions. Fundamentally, humans are primates. When observing primate behavior, we note a strong territorial instinct, often accompanied by efforts to expand their domain, a pattern consistently observed throughout human history. Humans are driven by the desire for control and power, and we are prepared to undertake any necessary actions to acquire and augment these. This is an inherent aspect of our existence. Religion emerged as one of the constructs stemming from our human nature. While our animalistic nature has evolved over time, these types of events would still transpire even in the absence of religious constructs.

reddit.com
u/CHOCOLATEDROP06 — 12 days ago