u/Cen9_65

Almost 0 of the critique on his life is logical almost all is emotional reasoning and I will be addressing the arguments on his wives and Aisha

1 Islam allowed 4 wives for Muslims but Mohammed had 9:

Many of his marriages weren’t out of lust and romance it was out of protection and status , helping different tribes and widows of fallen companions.

“Protection and status” Marriage gave Mohammed and the wife security in the tribe.

“Helping different tribes” some marriages reduced conflict and made alliances

“Widows of fallen companions” many women were left without support after war so Mohammed went and cared for them.

2 Aisha was 9 and Mohammed was over 50

At that time as long as the female was above the age of puberty it was fine and accepted for them to get married you can not judge a whole different system based on yours and to bring that up you must also accept Mary being 12-16 Rebecca being 3-16 and Moses in numbers letting his companions in war take young girls for themselves overall nothing was wrong with the marriage because it was at a very different time where that was the norm so you can’t judge him through our system for that.

Almost 0 of the critique on his life is logical almost all is emotional reasoning and I will be addressing the arguments on his wives and Aisha

1 Islam allowed 4 wives for Muslims but Mohammed had 9:

Many of his marriages weren’t out of lust and romance it was out of protection and status , helping different tribes and widows of fallen companions.

“Protection and status” Marriage gave Mohammed and the wife security in the tribe.

“Helping different tribes” some marriages reduced conflict and made alliances

“Widows of fallen companions” many women were left without support after war so Mohammed went and cared for them.

2 Aisha was 9 and Mohammed was over 50

At that time as long as the female was above the age of puberty it was fine and accepted for them to get married you can not judge a whole different system based on yours and to bring that up you must also accept Mary being 12-16 Rebecca being 3-16 and Moses in numbers letting his companions in war take young girls for themselves overall nothing was wrong with the marriage because it was at a very different time where that was the norm so you can’t judge him through our system for that.

The Christian doctrine of the Trinity is logically inconsistent because it forces a choice between polytheism and modalism, effectively undermining its claim to monotheism

Christians say they are 3 persons in the trinity that share the same essence so that makes them one but that response only deepens the mystery. Not to mention the mystery in the trinity is also being used like a “Get out of jail” card when they realise a contradiction.

This theology uses “being” and “person” all the time but they literally contradict the meaning to fit their narrative.

A being is an entity with its own self consciousness if a Christian accepts this they would have to accept each person in the trinity has their own self consciousness making them self aware 3 separate beings but counted as one. How though? The new question is how are 3 separate beings counted as one.

If you reject the definition of being and say they share one self consciousness making them one that risks falling into modalism so it’s either modalism or polytheism which both are not ideal.