CMV: “[…] is a human right” is not a good argument
Edit: my original point was that it’s not an effective rhetorical strategy or wording for trying to persuade someone who doesn’t already agree. I guess I wasn’t clear enough in my original post. I’m not a fascist guys I just want to hear better strategies for how to talk to the stupid and/or cruel people. Don’t be so mad at me :(
Basic shelter, food, water, stuff like that.
Obviously everyone needs it and deserves it but they don’t exist for free. Producing the stuff, maintaining or processing, transport, etc., all take labor that needs to be paid for.
The issue isn’t that these stuff should be (somehow, magically) free because everyone needs them, it’s that the costs should be shared by everyone because everyone needs them. And no one should be allowed to hoard that stuff because everyone needs them.
Just because we just collectively agree that something is a “basic inviolable human right” doesn’t mean that some sort of divine intervention will just make it so that we all get it, I don’t see why that sort of framing is necessary, or how it could be effective in persuading anyone who doesn’t already agree.