u/Charming-Jello2489

I honestly don't get the hate on Noah [I'm not heroine]

I honestly don't get the hate on Noah [I'm not heroine]

I recently started reading the manwha called I'm no heroine

Like Aerinda’s anger should’ve felt more justified and intense because:

she literally died

everyone misunderstood her

nobody properly defended her

her emotions were ignored

But then the narrative keeps softening everybody around her, so instead of:

> “these people failed her” it becomes: “it was all misunderstandings 🥺”

Which weakens the emotional impact.

And YES Serena (the OG FL) being able to sense emotions creates a huge issue because:

if she truly understood Aerinda’s pain/fear,

then just standing there during the execution feels morally questionable.

The story kinda avoids fully addressing that responsibility. Meanwhile Noah is being hated for no reason!

Noah is a dangerous villain,

misunderstood ML,

political threat,

or just possessive.

So Aerinda trying to separate him from Serena feels weird because:

in the original timeline he wasn’t even the direct cause of harm towards Serena but more like harming Aerinda...and I feel that it's kinda selfish .

PLUS if they wanted Noah to be this terrifying “villain ML,” they should’ve gone all in:

smarter schemes

stronger political control

more intimidating presence

morally darker actions

And made him more evil to hate on him instead he was treated like a laughing stock they keep telling us he’s dangerous without fully showing it consistently.

u/Charming-Jello2489 — 8 days ago