
Kobo Clara BW initial review
I’ve ditched my Kindle 10th Gen PW and am now trying a few different ereaders with the intent of keeping one and returning/selling the others. My use case: I’m mainly interested in books, either from the store, free sideloads and Libby. I’m also very interested in portability - I like to grab my ereader and run out to the coffee shop etc to spend some time with my books.
Right now I’m using the the Kobo Clara BW and the PocketBook Era Color to read alternating chapters in The Sympathizer. On the way from eBay is a Kobo Libra 2.
My first review here was of the PocketBook. Here’s what I think of the Clara BW.
The hardware: A pessimist might call this “cheap plastic,” but I think it’s actually kind of utilitarian. It’s a light, rigid plastic but well done for that. I like the sleep button being on the back corner - for some reason that feels like a more discreet-yet-accessible place for it than where the Kindle’s is, the bottom edge.
The ereader’s size is small and light enough that I can palm it in one hand with a little bit of stretching. I then finger tap the screen with my other hand.I know some people moan about the raised bezel, but it’s really not that bad - just maybe a millimeter or two off the screen proper. I actually kind of like it - it helps focus the gaze like a picture frame. I had an early-generation Nook, so I am completely familiar with dramatically raised bezels. This is not that.
Otherwise, that’s pretty much it for the physical part of it. I guess I would say that if the PocketBook Era Color feels akin to a nice, leather-bound hardcover, the Clara BW is equivalent to the paperback you can just throw in your pocket or bag without too much thought.
It was interesting to compare the Clara side by side with the Era. They’re almost the exact same height, but the Era has about 3/4 inch / 20mm in width.
The screen: If you don’t need color, the Clara BW’s screen is a much better option. Better contrast, better lighting, the fonts are much cleaner and crisper. It’s not subtle. I would get used to reading the Era Color - still not bad by any means - but then when I would switch back to the Clara BW and it would be like when the optometrist does the “Which is better - 3? Or 4?” thing with the lenses. Four, please. All day every day. It also feels easier on the eyes than the PocketBook Era Color, which needs more light to be legible.
UI: Better than the experience with the PocketBook for the most part. Libby felt a little more integrated. The ability to download books from the Rakuten site directly to the device helped to skip a sideloading step (even though I still eventually visit Calibre to strip the DRMs, add tags, etc). Native Instapaper integration is nice - if I see an interesting article while on my laptop, I just click the Instapaper browser extension and voila, it’s on the Clara.
The Kobo UI experience is good enough that I haven’t had much reason to use Koreader, tbh. The only tweek to the device I’ve made with Koreader was the “minimal homescreen” setup, which...eh.
Overall, I prefer the Clara for the reading experience, even if I prefer the PocketBook Era as a physical object. Maybe because of the Clara’s minimalism, it feels easier to get lost inside the literature. Still, having the book covers in e-ink is damned nice.
Still mulling these two. Kobo Libra 2 is scheduled to be delivered later this week.