The Search For The Leviathan Theory and 4/4 Theory
Okay. So what exactly did Wifies find here?
I think the biggest clue here is that Wifies references Ted Chiang’s “Hell Is the Absence of God.” In that story, God and Heaven are objectively real, but actually seeing proof doesn’t suddenly make the universe fair or understandable. Faith and divine reality are treated as two separate things, and I think that’s basically the rule behind Leviathan.
My theory is that the entire ocean investigation was never really about finding some giant sea monster. Hummer was testing whether Wifies could genuinely believe without keeping a safety net. Creative mode, the water breathing potion, etc. all “invalidate” it because as long as Wifies has a backup plan, he isn’t actually putting his faith in Levi. Only when he throws away the potion, lets the submarine get destroyed, and accepts that he could genuinely die does something finally happen.
And notice what happens after.
Levi never appears as a normal creature.
Instead, Wifies gets transported somewhere completely outside the normal server into this almost Heaven-like structure. That makes me think “Leviathan” isn’t really a sea creature at all, but some higher dimensional entity or intelligence, and this place is its domain.
The fact that Wifies suddenly can’t properly record or screenshot anything is also really important. It’s almost like the place itself prevents clean evidence from escaping. The only reason we even get to see it is because he records his monitor externally, which fits the whole cryptid theme from the beginning perfectly. Wifies finally gets proof, but it’s still the exact kind of weird, questionable evidence that everyone else could dismiss just like all those Reddit sightings.
Then there’s the thing in the chest at the end.. It looks like a Heart of the Sea, but the way it’s framed makes it look almost like an eye.
Wifies spends the entire video trying to observe Levi, finally reaches the center of this impossible place, looks directly into the “eye,” immediately passes out, and wakes up back on the normal server.
So maybe the twist is that Wifies was never the one observing Levi.
Levi was observing him.
I also really don’t think Hummer is just some random believer. He knows the “rules” way too specifically, constantly pushes Wifies to remove every possible escape route, and the supernatural event only happens once Wifies finally meets all of those conditions. Hummer feels more like some kind of herald, avatar, or guide whose job was never to help Wifies find Levi, but to make Wifies capable of reaching it.
And then there’s the 4/4 at the very end of the video at 1:27:58.
If you only watched this video, that probably seems completely random, but this has apparently been building across other Minecraft mystery videos for months. It started with a Lomedy video [“Disturbing Footage On A Minecraft Kids Channel”] that hid a coded message saying “One down, three more to go.”
This is solved through an A1Z26 Cipher. Each number corresponds to a letter’s position in the alphabet. A = 1, B = 2, ..., Z = 26. So 15-14-5 → O N E | 4-15-23-14 → D O W N | 20-8-18-5-5 → T H R E E | 13-15-18-5 → M O R E | 20-15 → T O | 7-15 → G O → | It reads ONE DOWN THREE MORE TO GO.
Then in ZachOBuilds video [“Finding the player that did this to him”] had another hidden message saying “Two down, two more to go.”
I honestly have no idea how people solved this one...
After that, Render uploaded [There's A Parasite Corrupting His Game...] another seemingly unrelated mystery that ended with “Three down, one remains.” Thankfully no decoding for this one.
People had already suspected that Wifies could be the fourth because of his connections to the other videos. So when his video ends with 4/4, it makes it look like whatever has been happening behind these four seemingly separate mysteries is finally complete.
What makes this even more interesting is that all four creators appear to have been directly contacted by the same source: Vex, or the Vex Syndicate.
Lomedy is emailed by Vex about the disturbing RunSonic kids channel.
Zach is emailed by Vex and told to look into the VipersDen subreddit because “there’s something bigger going on.”
Render is sent the Henry/Flowery case through the same Vex email connection.
And Wifies is given a shared folder called “Leviathan Reports (organized)” by thevex.syndicate@gmail.com.
There is an actual in-universe entity repeatedly handing these creators their cases.
That is why my current theory is that these four ARGs were not just random mysteries, but four tests conducted by the Vex Syndicate, and that every test revolves around the same central question:
How do you know something is real?
Lomedy has to reconstruct the truth through someone else’s recordings while grief, instability, and a strange fox-like entity make it unclear what can actually be trusted.
Zach’s story is built almost entirely around deception. Viper impersonates people, manipulates accounts, sets up moral tests, and constantly makes Ace question who is really behind what he’s seeing.
Render goes another layer removed. Jake is investigating prerecorded footage left behind by his missing brother, meaning everything he knows has to come from incomplete and potentially corrupted evidence.
And then Wifies is different.
He doesn’t just investigate someone else’s encounter.
He becomes the encounter.
That gives the four stories a really interesting progression:
testimony → deception → corrupted evidence → direct revelation without proof
All four are basically testing epistemology: what are you willing to accept as real when your normal methods of proving reality stop working?
And that makes the name “The Rabbit Hole” feel extremely intentional. ARGs themselves work the exact same way. You keep following evidence deeper and deeper until eventually you’re no longer sure where the fictional mystery ends and the larger story begins.
Which is why I don’t think the Vex Syndicate is simply sending these YouTubers cool mysteries to make videos about.
I think the YouTubers themselves are being tested.
Each one has shown that they’re willing to keep investigating even when the evidence becomes unreliable, dangerous, or impossible to explain. The countdown may literally be tracking completed subjects:
One down.
Two down.
Three down.
4/4.
So the four videos could essentially be a recruitment process.
Vex isn’t counting monsters.
They’re counting investigators.
And now that all four are complete, I think the next stage is where the supposedly separate ARGs finally collide. Lomedy, Zach, Render, and Wifies may all discover that their cases were chosen for them deliberately, and that Vex has been watching how each of them responds to the impossible.
The really interesting question then becomes why Vex needed four people capable of going this far down the rabbit hole in the first place.
And going back to Leviathan, that could make Wifies especially important.
The first three investigators were still separated from the supernatural by recordings, accounts, or other people’s experiences.
Wifies was the first one to actually cross the boundary himself.
He spent the entire video trying to prove that Levi was real.
But by the end, maybe that wasn’t the test at all.
Maybe the test was whether Wifies was ready to be seen by it.