u/Consistent-Ad1453

A sincere thanks again to everyone who offered feedback on this investigator over the weekend! I took your critiques seriously and completely revised him, including his stats, ability, deckbuilding, and signatures.

I'd love to hear what y'all think about these revisions. I decided that a "Calling In Favors" type of investigator ability would work better for what I was going for with him, and I added uses to his signature Ally to allow him to "use" other allies at his location for his benefit. I'm thinking it might be a good idea to give him 2 signatures and put the "Favors" uses onto a different card, maybe a "ledger" or something like that.

I look forward to hearing your thoughts! I love the feedback/criticisms you all have offered so far, so please keep them coming! I take none of your critiques personally! I genuinely want to improve my designs for these cards. 😁

I've had a great time discussing and reading feedback from you all about the other custom investigators I've designed based on the characters from the Vampire: the Masquerade actual play series, LA by Night.

Here are two more from the series that I'd love to get feedback on! Like the others, I've tried to design them to match the character's flavor from the show while making them viable investigators for Arkham. I'm also trying to make them distinct from official investigators they may resemble (namely Charlie Kane and 2026 Marie Lambeau for these two).

Thank you all in advance for your feedback!

In addition to my love of VtM and LA by Night, I love Arkham Horror: The Card Game, so I decided to create some custom investigators and player cards based on LA by Night. My intention has been to stay as thematically consistent with the characters while making them work within the mechanics and rules of Arkham Horror.

If anyone has thoughts or suggestions for improvement, please let me know! I've planned out cards for Victor Temple, X, and Eva, but I just haven't had a chance to make them yet. They will be coming soon, though.

Note: I couldn't find artwork for Carver that worked with my vision, so if you have any suggestions for artwork by people. (No AI slop, please; I can do that myself if I felt compelled to do so.) Also, if anyone knows who the artist is for the Nelli G illustration, please let me know so I can give them credit!

Thank you in advance for any feedback you want to offer!

Apologies for posting custom content twice in one day. I finished a draft of my third custom investigator in this series, and I'm looking for feedback.

Like the other two investigators I posted, this one is also based off of a character from the Vampire: the Masquerade actual play series LA by Night on YouTube. My intention behind this design is to match the character's flavor as much as possible but still make it work well with the rules and mechanics of Arkham.

Please let me know if you have any comments or suggestions for improvement, especially if you know LA by Night. Thank you!

A sincere "Thank you!!" to everyone who offered feedback on the previous iterations of my custom Annabelle Li and Nelli G investigators from Vampire: the Masquerade! I've taken everyone's feedback and made new versions (including actual art made by humans for Nelli G's cards). More feedback is always welcome!

I'm a bit torn on whether to give Annabelle Li a 4 or a 5 in her combat score. Her revised signature asset kind of makes her a 5 Combat investigator (but only for basic attacks), but she has to find it and play it first. I'd love to hear folks' thoughts on that.

The biggest change for Annabelle is that she now has a different signature weakness that directly impacts her ability. Several folks mentioned that her previous signature weakness would have been one of the softest in the game, so I decided to scrap it as a signature weakness. A version of that card might become a basic weakness, though.

Nelli G's cards are basically the same except with new art. I didn't feel good about using AI slop, so I found art that works for what I'm going for.

Thanks again to everyone for your thoughtful comments! Please, keep them coming!

I've finished drafting my second custom investigator from the Vampire the Masquerade actual play. LA by Night. Like the Annabelle Li investigator, I designed this character as to fit the flavor of her character from the show.

As you will see, I have multiple versions of her signature cards, and I'd love to hear the community's feedback on all of the cards you see here. I also tried to make her feel distinct from official investigators, but I'd love to hear your thoughts on how I might improve them overall.

Disclaimer: The "art" I used was generated by AI. I tried *very* hard to find art from actual artists for these cards, but I couldn't find anything that quite fit what I was looking for. I don't love the idea of using AI slop for the artwork, but it'll do for now. If you have any suggestions for actual art that you think might work better, please feel free to share it! I want to support human artists as much as possible.