u/CountryStrange2119

We’ve been looking for a while for a Sienna. We found an XLE, AWD about a 5 hour drive from us that I’m going to get this weekend. 33k miles on it, price is $44790. We put a refundable deposit on it last weekend and then sold our truck earlier this week to fund our down payment.
Last night I was rechecking KBB and Edmund’s and the value has dropped $3k. We haven’t signed anything with the dealership, just that deposit of $500 to hold it for us.
I’d like to negotiate the price down. Should I just send screen shots of the fair market value from those sites and request they adjust the price? We do want this van, but don’t want to be suckers and over pay. My in laws have a spare car we’re borrowing since we sold our truck so we aren’t desperate.
I’m probably over thinking this so please be kind. I’m a woman, 7.5 months pregnant with our second, hate negotiating, and just want to get this process over with 🥲😬

Okay, now we’ve decided that we really want to have no car payment. Ultimately the cost of gas sucks but the added costs of hybrids make it so we wouldn’t save money for YEARS so we’d rather save money with no car payment right now.

So it’s down to a 2018 and up Honda Odyssey (as long as it’s below $25k) or a 2017-2021 Toyota Sienna (same parameters). I’ve found a 2018 XLE Sienna for $21,229 local-ish to me (2.5 hour drive) with 100k miles. I’m on the west coast so cars last. It’s FWD but that doesn’t worry me much. It snows like once a year where I live and we will have a farm truck with 4WD if we ever need something more. Reason for those numbers is that I’ve gotten used to having dynamic cruise control and the keys that unlock the door for me (or don’t let you lock them inside, I do that weekly).

We’d love to be at 100k miles or a little less. Should I still be looking at the Honda? We’ve had Toyotas for 10 years and have had 0 issues. I feel so loyal to my Toyotas… they’ve truly been wonderful cars.

nother one for the classic debate of Honda Odyssey versus Toyota Sienna…

Family of 3 soon to be 4. Also have 2 dogs. We’re ready for a minivan. We do a lot of road trips and I’m tired of getting my toddler in and out of my tiny Prius. I don’t like SUVs, I want those sliding doors of a minivan!! We are going to sell our Toyota Tacoma for about $25k to help with the cost of a minivan.

There’s a dealership somewhat local to us (4 hour drive away but we visit family there all of the time). They have a 2023 Touring Honda Odyssey with 49k miles for $26k. They also have a 2024 Limited Sienna with 29k miles for $39k.

We could have no car payment on the Honda but would have larger gas costs…

We like both vans. Honda drives so much nicer but fuel economy does matter to us. But it seems like it would take about 7 years with that cost difference for fuel economy to even matter? We are keeping our Prius to have a fuel efficient vehicle but it has 160k miles so it’s not a guarantee on how long she’ll last…

Another one for the classic debate of Honda Odyssey versus Toyota Sienna…

Family of 3 soon to be 4. Also have 2 dogs. We’re ready for a minivan. We do a lot of road trips and I’m tired of getting my toddler in and out of my tiny Prius. I don’t like SUVs, I want those sliding doors of a minivan!! We are going to sell our Toyota Tacoma for about $25k to help with the cost of a minivan.

There’s a dealership somewhat local to us (4 hour drive away but we visit family there all of the time). They have a 2023 Touring Honda Odyssey with 49k miles for $26k. They also have a 2024 Limited Sienna with 29k miles for $39k.

We could have no car payment on the Honda but would have larger gas costs…

We like both vans. Honda drives so much nicer but fuel economy does matter to us. But it seems like it would take about 7 years with that cost difference for fuel economy to even matter? We are keeping our Prius to have a fuel efficient vehicle but it has 160k miles so it’s not a guarantee on how long she’ll last…

Hello! We’ve been a happy Toyota family with my Prius (2017) and Tacoma (2019). Have had super reliable cars and been really happy with them. But I’m pregnant with baby number 2 and I’m ready for the minivan life. Right now we’re set on selling or trading in our Tacoma (will get a beater farm truck since we do live on 5 acres). There’s a 2021 XLE local to me listed for $27k. It has 111k miles on it. It’s with a dealership so pro would be easy trade in. Unfortunately we really can’t swing new right now. But I guess I’m having a hard time swallowing that price with that high mileage.

Any input on that make/year? Good deal/bad deal?