Askibng for shop critique — 2 weeks in and looking for feedback
Hi everyone! I opened my Etsy shop about two weeks ago, and I’m looking for some honest feedback on what I could improve. I sell printable Christian/Bible study resources, primarily designed to help people spend more intentional time studying and applying Scripture.
I’m still very new to this Etsy thing, so I know there are probably things I’m overlooking. I’d especially appreciate feedback on these parts of my shop:
- Do my listing photos and thumbnails clearly communicate what the customer is actually getting? Are there any changes you would make to the way I present the digital products?
- Does my overall shop/listing SEO seem strong enough? I’d appreciate any feedback on my titles, tags, descriptions, or keywords that could help my products reach the right audience. This is one area I especially, do not know how to improve.
- What avenues of marketing have you found to be most successful? I am struggling in this area. I have tried a little on Pinterest. Are there other free avenues that I could take to market my product and drive more traffic to my etsy shop?
What inspired you to create this shop?
I wanted to create practical tools that encourage people to spend more intentional time in God's Word. There are a lot of Christian printables available, but I wanted to focus on simple resources that are actually useful during personal Bible study rather than making products that are primarily decorative. I also noticed that products in this area on etsy were largely AI generated which made me sad, so part of this was a desire to see more human-designed products on the market.
What research have you already done on your shop prior to opening? What is something you learned from that research?
Before opening, I spent quite a bit of time looking through other Etsy shops selling Bible study printables and similar Christian resources. I looked at their listing photos, product formats, titles, keywords, pricing, and how they organized their shops. I've also watched several youtube videos. One thing I learned was that having a good product is only part of the equation. The listing needs to clearly communicate the value of the product and make it easy for someone to understand what they're getting.
Here is my shop: https://stongholdpaperco.etsy.com
Thanks in advance to anyone willing to take the time to look through it. I’m mainly looking for constructive criticism so I can make the shop better while it’s still new.